Sociology
Understanding Global Civilizations: Breaking Down Arrogance and Cultural Biases in Human History
Articles • Hasan09 posted the article • 0 comments • 32 views • 2026-11-09 10:56
[Internet Repost]
Standing on the rugged loess soil of the Liupan Mountains, I want to explore the deep-seated barriers in communication between the world’s major civilizations from both historical and contemporary perspectives. By dissecting the divisions caused by cultural centrism and cognitive arrogance, we must call for an open-minded approach grounded in humble listening and mutual respect to foster meaningful dialogue among diverse cultures.
The loess mountains look grim in the morning light, with gully after gully stacked up like faded scripture pages that you want to read but can never quite make out. I’m standing on the shadowed slope of the Liupan Mountains. Beneath my feet is a mountain path polished smooth by snow, and in the distance, the leftover snow still glimmers on the ridges of Xihaigu, a bone-chilling white like an old vow buried deep in the earth that refuses to fade away even in this day and age. A wind blows down from the north, carrying sand, bits of dry grass, and half-heard languages, pushing one far away from the familiar edges of home.
I’ve always felt that certain questions have to be asked at passes like this—in the hours when the wind is howling and the snow is just about to lock everything down—only then can the heart be truly honest. For example, how do we understand the "mainstream cultures" that everyone talks about these days: Chinese, Islamic, Western, or the songs and drumbeats of Africa? Talk about this at a desk, and it sounds greasy; say it while walking on the loess soil, and your tongue feels heavy and the words turn hard.
I’m carrying an old, well-worn backpack filled with scholars' books and a few printed papers with English titles, all discussing how civilization, faith, and the human mind are molded by different cultures. The data in labs is cold, and I always feel a bit of hesitation bringing those charts and curves into these parched loess ravines. But since we live in an age where science is the yardstick, I can't just rely on intuition like I used to, so I have to force these cold graphs and the coarse soil together to see if they can still make a real, honest sound.
The long mountain path stretches forward, flanked by mud houses with walls stained dark brown by years of smoke, and ice hanging from the eaves like rows upon rows of frozen question marks. Black goats on the ridges are scattered among the gravel and melting snow, heads bobbing as they tear dry grass from the ground. A sliver of a moon hangs on the horizon, as grey and white as bone, lingering in the narrow space between the sunlight and the wind.
On mornings like this, I like to imagine the four cultures as four winds blowing from different directions, colliding and tangling on this uneven rock we call the world. Anthropologists have long reminded us that culture isn't a flat map; it's a piece of rugged terrain where multiple highlands rise simultaneously, with different civilizations feeling their way up their own slopes, and no one can take another’s steps for them. It’s just that as history unfolded, it was written as a single line. Many writers took the easy way out, starting the clock on the other side of the distant ocean, then using a thick line to turn the scale of civilization into a rigid ruler, leaving the world measured and broken into scattered pieces.
When I read those books in my youth, I felt anxious. The books depicted Chinese civilization as an ancient and enclosed basin, the Islamic world as a mixture of passion and tradition, and Africans as reduced to songs, tribes, and scars. As for the West, there was only a sense of taken-for-granted affirmation—science, reason, the individual, and rights—as if these words could only naturally describe one region, one skin color. Years later, sitting in the mud houses of Xihaigu, on the Gobi Desert of Xinjiang, or beside the ice-thawed riverbeds of the north, I sifted through those claims over and over, slowly learning to re-examine those high-gloss, preconceived terms against the much harsher reality.
I suspect that only by standing on our own solid earth can these four cultures truly reveal themselves, like four travelers arriving from afar, each carrying their own dust and old wounds, sitting together in a mud cabin where the fire is small, the tea is weak, and no one tries to speak too loudly.
The Loess Plateau speaks first.
The culture of this land doesn't rely on noisy proclamations; it presses its truths beneath the soil, burying memories between desolate graves and residual snow. Scholars love to talk about "civilization types" or the "Axial Age," framing Chinese civilization as a massive entity with a skeleton of texts, rituals, and dynasties, as if all that rolled across this continent was just a political history from the Zhou Dynasty to today. Having spent so much time in the villages, I feel more and more that this view is far too dismissive of the grassroots.
The true roots of China are rarely in temples or stone tablets, but in the dark corners of loess cave dwellings, in the breath exhaled on the edge of a *kang* (heated brick bed) in deep winter, and in the feet of farmers silently stepping into the silt after a flood. Modern scholarship is beginning to shift this way, with sociology and anthropology studies moving their focus from the center to the edges, claiming to rewrite a bottom-up history of China and seeking to understand a society of "relational embeddedness"—where people aren't isolated individuals, but are bound by invisible ropes of kinship, local roots, and integrity. The networks woven by these ropes are thicker than legal clauses and more solid than the discourse of rights.
While these theories circle each other on paper, the loess has already lived them out. The mud houses of Xihaigu, the long paths between mountains, the calloused hands of the farmers, the muffled sighs of women at night—these are all nodes in this network. It defines what it means to be "home," what "human sentiment" is, what "face" is, and what "shame" is. It also answers the question "Who am I?" very specifically—I am the son of this family in this village, a person in this gully, a handful of soil by the ancestral graves.
With Chinese culture so deeply rooted, it naturally has an instinctive reaction to the winds from outside. It is not showy, not easily excited, and its wariness is laced with curiosity, while its curiosity carries a simple self-confidence. For over a century, the winds of the West, Islam, and Africa have all swept across this land. City dwellers quickly learned to use words like "globalization," but the Loess Plateau is more cautious; it first tests the temperature of these winds with its own thick soil. What it can handle, it absorbs and turns into a new layer of itself; winds that blow too fast are made to circle the mountain passes twice and slow down.
On the other side of the Liupan Mountains, I encountered the wind of Islam.
It was a day of heavy snow that sealed the mountains, leaving the ridges of Xihaigu a uniform grey and white. In a mud house in a village, I heard an elder softly reciting scriptures—not in the uniform tone heard in city mosques, but with a local accent, family whispers, long-suppressed frustrations, and a humble sense of pride. The word "Islam" is too vast on a world map; when scholars write about it, they often get stuck in the shadows of politics and violence, rarely lowering their heads to see how ordinary believers maintain their discipline in a desolate life.
The Islam I saw in the loess cave dwellings wasn't some abstract buzzword, but a low-key, disciplined way of life. Washing hands and faces, raising hands for *dua* (supplication/prayer), observing dietary restrictions, holding one's tongue, and when suffering bears down, leaving behind a word of "submission." But that submission isn't surrender to power; it’s a form of finding peace within oneself amidst misery. I later read research in religion and cognitive science suggesting that long-term prayer and collective *masjid* (mosque) worship strengthen brain regions related to communal feeling and order, making it easier for people to experience the existence of a "community" and enhancing unity and endurance in hardship. These differences, visible in cold charts, were long ago etched into these barren mountain villages.
Islamic culture is like a river winding from deserts, oases, and grasslands. It passed through the ethnic groups of our Northwest, leaving behind clean diets, solemn rituals, and generous hospitality, along with a stubbornness that refuses to retreat easily. I walked through empty valleys and heard young shepherds talk of distant holy lands, their eyes gleaming in the moonlight; inside them was a faith in ultimate justice, an expectation of divine judgment, and a longing for the grievances of this life to be washed away in the next world.
Compared to a culture that finds its return in "The One," Chinese civilization is more like a thick clay accustomed to compromise and harmony, allowing for multiple gods and ancestors to coexist. It permits Confucianism, Buddhism, and Taoism to layer upon each other, allowing ancestral tablets to sit alongside abstract concepts. So when the two meet, tensions inevitably arise at certain points: one emphasizes absolute truth, the other is used to diversity; one emphasizes commandments, the other trusts more in human sentiment. But what I saw on the Northwest Loess Plateau was another scene entirely—the two cultures avoiding direct collision, choosing instead to live quietly side-by-side in daily life.
I still remember those times in the residual snow of Xihaigu when people gathered for the collective visiting of graves. The loess ridge was all white, and people gathered from every direction; white headscarves fluttered in the wind, and the repressed historical memories in their chests were awakened by unified movements and sounds. It was a belief forged through tragic events and the cost of blood, a spiritual history rarely written about head-on in mainstream textbooks. Every major religion in the world has been embroiled in power and violence in some way, but in the daily lives of these grassroots believers, faith acts more like a rope that pulls people out of failure and poverty, allowing them to keep a shred of dignity in extreme hardship.
Crossing the Tianshan Mountains, I heard ballads on the grasslands that blended Islamic and nomadic traditions. Under the vast sky, the stars were cold; human voices blended with drumbeats, and saddles and sandalwood paperweights bore witness to time sinking suffering into the internal textures of the soul. The modern World-Systems theory loves to talk about "center-periphery," placing the Islamic world and many parts of Africa and Latin America at the exploited end, discussing economics, resources, and trade structures. Structurally, these points have merit, but I always feel they can't fully capture the soul of a people.
In that vastness, I felt another confrontation: facing the single-path narrative represented by the West, those civilizations classified as "the periphery" are silently maintaining a different cosmic order with their own scriptures, drumbeats, and desolate graves on the loess soil.
The wind of Western culture has been blowing across the seas and into our continent for a long time.
Books tell me its core is reason, science, the individual, and rights—a whole set of cognitive methods supported by empiricism, laboratories, and mathematical models. As anthropologists lament the disintegration of traditional societies, young people in many places have already learned to use this logic to explain the world: the world can be precisely measured, history can be pushed linearly, and the individual is a self-sufficient unit that can separate from family and the earth, connecting with others solely through contracts and law.
I don't deny the value of these achievements. Modern natural science has liberated many from disease and hunger, peeled back the structure of the universe bit by bit, and stripped away layers of human cognitive bias. Interdisciplinary research in cognitive psychology, cultural neuroscience, and anthropology allows us to see that people in different cultures truly leave traces in their brains regarding their understanding of self, groups, and fairness. These findings help us recognize differences more calmly and stop easily judging entire civilizations as "superior" or "inferior."
The problem arises when this way of explaining the world is absolutized by some, treated as the only yardstick, and the richness of other civilizations is compressed into being "pre-modern" or "backward." World-systems theorists, post-colonial scholars, and researchers of civilizational diversity have spent decades deconstructing this single-line theory. They tell us that Western modernity is also a specific historical path, the result of a specific geography, religion, and economic structure, rather than a universal template that everyone must follow.
Standing on the banks of a river in the North as the ice began to break, I spent a long time thinking about this. As the ice on the river started to shift, water came roaring up from underneath, pushing the jagged chunks aside, and when the sunlight hit it, the surface glistened. In that moment, I knew clearly: if any one culture on this planet claims the title of 'modern' exclusively, leaving no room for other civilizations to speak, that is a dangerous kind of poverty.
Western culture offers a powerful toolkit—scientific methods, institutional design, human rights discourse, and democratic ideals. These are things countries across the globe can selectively borrow to improve their lives, build fairer societies, and protect human dignity. But it cannot, and should not, erase the depth of the Chinese loess plateau, the devotion found in Islamic scriptures, or the rhythm of life in African drumbeats.
When I think of African culture, I’m reminded of a young man I met in the borderlands who had just returned from his studies in Africa. At a snowy outpost, he told me about grasslands beyond the ones I knew—where the grass is greener, the sky is bluer, and cattle and drumbeats interweave by evening campfires. He talked about village elders, market chants, the patterns painted on skin during rituals, and how they navigate between the memory of colonialism and the hope for the future. Anthropologists have long listened to those voices in the forests and the Sahel region of Africa, documenting oral histories, myths, and kinship systems, while reflecting on the arrogance that once used evolutionary theories to hold others down.
For a long time, the true depth of African civilization was misunderstood by the world. Some media outlets only like to focus on war, disease, and poverty as the main themes, occasionally tossing in a shallow nod to 'primitive joy.' This kind of narrative is neither fair nor serious. Later scholarship has begun to correct this, highlighting the complexity of Africa's diverse ethnic groups, languages, and religions, emphasizing the wisdom in oral traditions, and focusing on ethics centered on the collective and a deep sensitivity to natural rhythms.
Behind those words, I always picture another scene I’ve seen on the grasslands of the Northwest: the withering and flourishing of wild grass, the movement of groups, the blending of drumbeats and horse hooves, where people feel as much like dust as they do sparks of fire. The dancing of African people under the scorching sun and the rhythm of their drums aren't so different in spirit from the long, flowing folk songs of our Northern grasslands, the drumbeats of Central Asia, or the dua (supplication/prayer) of the Arab world. They are all humanity’s shared response to the earth, to life, and to death—using the body to remember and rhythm to face an unknowable fate.
Thinking about this amid the heavy snowfall in the Liupan Mountains, a rough map of the human spirit began to unfold in my mind.
Chinese civilization is like a great loess mountain—topped with residual snow, rooted in ancient graves; the legal and ritual codes are like layers of stacked earth, with scriptures buried alongside farming tools. Islamic civilization is like a river flowing from a sea of sand, lingering near the snow line, carrying a strict rhythm that washes away human desires again and again, teaching people to find freedom within discipline. Western civilization is like a machine that is constantly self-deconstructing and reassembling, skilled at looking at itself with skepticism, upgrading its tools, and measuring the world with precision. African culture is like a grassland panting in the heat: the surface is all dance and song, but underneath lies a profound, lingering trauma and resilience, rising again and again after being beaten down, using the rhythm of the body to mend the cracks left by history.
These labels have their limitations, but I’m no longer interested in swapping them for fancier terms. Academia already has too many complex concepts: dialogue of civilizations, multiple modernities, post-colonial context, cultural psychological structures... these words have their place, and I’ve been inspired by them too. But standing at the doorway of a mud house in Xihaigu, watching black goats forage for grass on the edge of the snow above an old cave dwelling, I trust the simplest judgment more—every civilization has tempered its bones in extreme environments and has its own way of upholding human dignity.
The problem isn't the differences themselves; the problem is the arrogance.
The pattern of the world’s mainstream culture isn't a fixed table; it’s a flowing river. The Chinese, Islamic, Western, and African traditions have all been pushed to the center or the margins at different points in history. In our era, technology and capital make information move fast, making some discourses easy to amplify and other voices easy to drown out. The media loves chasing the 'mainstream' label, as if whatever is mentioned most often is the core, while the quiet, the patient, and the remote can be ignored.
Having stood before the abandoned graves in Xihaigu for a long time, another bottom line formed in my heart: what defines a civilization shouldn't be its volume, but how it treats its weakest members. Whether the most marginalized people in a culture—the poor, the sick, minorities, the downtrodden—can still maintain basic dignity and aren't treated as disposable, that is the true litmus test.
Chinese civilization uses patriarchal clans and local community bonds to weave the isolated individual into a network of kinship and geography; even if it’s rudimentary, it provides them with a meal and a place to stand. Islamic doctrine, through almsgiving and communal dua, allows the most impoverished to find their place within the collective. Western rights discourse uses institutions to build defenses for the weak; though imperfect, it at least establishes a standard to hold power publicly accountable. African village traditions use sharing and festivals to let those living through famine and war catch their breath within the rhythm of the group.
None of these approaches are pure; all carry the risk of being co-opted by power or swallowed by the market. Yet, in the wind and snow of the Liupan Mountains, under the dim light of a mud house, in the long winds of the grasslands, and among the drumbeats at the intersection of forest and desert, I still choose to believe in a stubborn, cleansing spirit that appears in different civilizations under different names, resisting the cold tendency to treat human beings as mere tools or numbers.
I walk along the long mountain road, the ground beneath my feet frozen hard, the path ahead rising in segments. Behind me is the heavy memory this land has pressed upon me; in front of me is a world surrounded by all sorts of 'mainstream' terminology.
How to understand the world’s mainstream culture is a question that, for many who call themselves intellectuals, easily becomes a word game. They move concepts around in their studies and rank the superiority of civilizations in lecture halls, talking about tolerance and dialogue while their eyes are often clouded with the arrogance of perspective. I don't want to repeat their path.
I would rather respond in a slower way: walking on the loess mountains, standing by the residual snow in Xihaigu, listening to the night wind in a mud house, touching the damp earth in front of a weathered cave dwelling, and then bringing the theories of distant civilizations, small experimental data, and those so-called cutting-edge theories, one by one, to this place—setting them on the earthen kang (heated brick bed) and beside the lonely graves, just to see how much weight they truly hold.
Perhaps in the end, I will only get some blurry answers:
Chinese civilization teaches me that a person must have a sense of shame; even if you're so poor that all you have left is rags, you must hold onto a bottom line that cannot be sold. Islamic civilization reminds me that there are judgments in this world higher than the pursuit of a livelihood, and beliefs more stable than current power; one should not forget the longing for ultimate justice. Western civilization forces me to learn how to doubt myself, to use the light of reason to illuminate blind faith, to restrain power with institutions, and to reflect on prejudices with science. African culture, meanwhile, helps me remember that the movement of the body and the drumbeat of the collective can carry trauma, that memory isn't just found on paper, and dignity isn't maintained by words alone.
These realizations are rough and unsystematic; they wouldn't hold up in an academic debate. But I am willing to stand by them because they were gained through walking, honed bit by bit in the wind and snow, on the loess soil, and before the residual snow on abandoned graves.
I head back from the snowy road of the Liupan Mountains as twilight approaches. The black goats on the ridge are being herded into their pens, the waning moon hangs higher, and a faint, dim yellow light filters through the cracks in the mud cottage windows. The snow on the old graves grows deeper, the shadows of the crumbling cave dwellings grow darker, and the wind circles the earthen slopes.
The world's mainstream culture is debating in far-off places, shouting slogans in conference halls, on the internet, and on paper. I cannot hear those echoes; I only hear the silence emanating from the ground beneath my feet.
Perhaps one day, when these four winds blow harder, and more children hold books from distant lands in their hands, learning the languages of other places through screens, they will understand the big words—Chinese, Islamic, Western, African—in new ways, finding more precise explanations in new laboratories and fields. I am no longer young, and I won't be around for that final conclusion.
All I can do is write down these feelings from the loess today and pass them on to those younger than me.
When that time comes, if they happen to pass through the Liupan Mountains in the deep snow, walk past the mud houses, and weave between the black goats on the ridge and the snow-covered graves, they might suddenly feel a touch of hesitation: when faced with the glittering mainstream of the distant world, how should one place one's own steps? How to be neither kneeling nor drawing a sword? How to be neither inferior nor blindly arrogant?
If they find themselves stuck with this question, then I will know that this long mountain road was not walked in vain. view all
Standing on the rugged loess soil of the Liupan Mountains, I want to explore the deep-seated barriers in communication between the world’s major civilizations from both historical and contemporary perspectives. By dissecting the divisions caused by cultural centrism and cognitive arrogance, we must call for an open-minded approach grounded in humble listening and mutual respect to foster meaningful dialogue among diverse cultures.
The loess mountains look grim in the morning light, with gully after gully stacked up like faded scripture pages that you want to read but can never quite make out. I’m standing on the shadowed slope of the Liupan Mountains. Beneath my feet is a mountain path polished smooth by snow, and in the distance, the leftover snow still glimmers on the ridges of Xihaigu, a bone-chilling white like an old vow buried deep in the earth that refuses to fade away even in this day and age. A wind blows down from the north, carrying sand, bits of dry grass, and half-heard languages, pushing one far away from the familiar edges of home.
I’ve always felt that certain questions have to be asked at passes like this—in the hours when the wind is howling and the snow is just about to lock everything down—only then can the heart be truly honest. For example, how do we understand the "mainstream cultures" that everyone talks about these days: Chinese, Islamic, Western, or the songs and drumbeats of Africa? Talk about this at a desk, and it sounds greasy; say it while walking on the loess soil, and your tongue feels heavy and the words turn hard.
I’m carrying an old, well-worn backpack filled with scholars' books and a few printed papers with English titles, all discussing how civilization, faith, and the human mind are molded by different cultures. The data in labs is cold, and I always feel a bit of hesitation bringing those charts and curves into these parched loess ravines. But since we live in an age where science is the yardstick, I can't just rely on intuition like I used to, so I have to force these cold graphs and the coarse soil together to see if they can still make a real, honest sound.
The long mountain path stretches forward, flanked by mud houses with walls stained dark brown by years of smoke, and ice hanging from the eaves like rows upon rows of frozen question marks. Black goats on the ridges are scattered among the gravel and melting snow, heads bobbing as they tear dry grass from the ground. A sliver of a moon hangs on the horizon, as grey and white as bone, lingering in the narrow space between the sunlight and the wind.
On mornings like this, I like to imagine the four cultures as four winds blowing from different directions, colliding and tangling on this uneven rock we call the world. Anthropologists have long reminded us that culture isn't a flat map; it's a piece of rugged terrain where multiple highlands rise simultaneously, with different civilizations feeling their way up their own slopes, and no one can take another’s steps for them. It’s just that as history unfolded, it was written as a single line. Many writers took the easy way out, starting the clock on the other side of the distant ocean, then using a thick line to turn the scale of civilization into a rigid ruler, leaving the world measured and broken into scattered pieces.
When I read those books in my youth, I felt anxious. The books depicted Chinese civilization as an ancient and enclosed basin, the Islamic world as a mixture of passion and tradition, and Africans as reduced to songs, tribes, and scars. As for the West, there was only a sense of taken-for-granted affirmation—science, reason, the individual, and rights—as if these words could only naturally describe one region, one skin color. Years later, sitting in the mud houses of Xihaigu, on the Gobi Desert of Xinjiang, or beside the ice-thawed riverbeds of the north, I sifted through those claims over and over, slowly learning to re-examine those high-gloss, preconceived terms against the much harsher reality.
I suspect that only by standing on our own solid earth can these four cultures truly reveal themselves, like four travelers arriving from afar, each carrying their own dust and old wounds, sitting together in a mud cabin where the fire is small, the tea is weak, and no one tries to speak too loudly.
The Loess Plateau speaks first.
The culture of this land doesn't rely on noisy proclamations; it presses its truths beneath the soil, burying memories between desolate graves and residual snow. Scholars love to talk about "civilization types" or the "Axial Age," framing Chinese civilization as a massive entity with a skeleton of texts, rituals, and dynasties, as if all that rolled across this continent was just a political history from the Zhou Dynasty to today. Having spent so much time in the villages, I feel more and more that this view is far too dismissive of the grassroots.
The true roots of China are rarely in temples or stone tablets, but in the dark corners of loess cave dwellings, in the breath exhaled on the edge of a *kang* (heated brick bed) in deep winter, and in the feet of farmers silently stepping into the silt after a flood. Modern scholarship is beginning to shift this way, with sociology and anthropology studies moving their focus from the center to the edges, claiming to rewrite a bottom-up history of China and seeking to understand a society of "relational embeddedness"—where people aren't isolated individuals, but are bound by invisible ropes of kinship, local roots, and integrity. The networks woven by these ropes are thicker than legal clauses and more solid than the discourse of rights.
While these theories circle each other on paper, the loess has already lived them out. The mud houses of Xihaigu, the long paths between mountains, the calloused hands of the farmers, the muffled sighs of women at night—these are all nodes in this network. It defines what it means to be "home," what "human sentiment" is, what "face" is, and what "shame" is. It also answers the question "Who am I?" very specifically—I am the son of this family in this village, a person in this gully, a handful of soil by the ancestral graves.
With Chinese culture so deeply rooted, it naturally has an instinctive reaction to the winds from outside. It is not showy, not easily excited, and its wariness is laced with curiosity, while its curiosity carries a simple self-confidence. For over a century, the winds of the West, Islam, and Africa have all swept across this land. City dwellers quickly learned to use words like "globalization," but the Loess Plateau is more cautious; it first tests the temperature of these winds with its own thick soil. What it can handle, it absorbs and turns into a new layer of itself; winds that blow too fast are made to circle the mountain passes twice and slow down.
On the other side of the Liupan Mountains, I encountered the wind of Islam.
It was a day of heavy snow that sealed the mountains, leaving the ridges of Xihaigu a uniform grey and white. In a mud house in a village, I heard an elder softly reciting scriptures—not in the uniform tone heard in city mosques, but with a local accent, family whispers, long-suppressed frustrations, and a humble sense of pride. The word "Islam" is too vast on a world map; when scholars write about it, they often get stuck in the shadows of politics and violence, rarely lowering their heads to see how ordinary believers maintain their discipline in a desolate life.
The Islam I saw in the loess cave dwellings wasn't some abstract buzzword, but a low-key, disciplined way of life. Washing hands and faces, raising hands for *dua* (supplication/prayer), observing dietary restrictions, holding one's tongue, and when suffering bears down, leaving behind a word of "submission." But that submission isn't surrender to power; it’s a form of finding peace within oneself amidst misery. I later read research in religion and cognitive science suggesting that long-term prayer and collective *masjid* (mosque) worship strengthen brain regions related to communal feeling and order, making it easier for people to experience the existence of a "community" and enhancing unity and endurance in hardship. These differences, visible in cold charts, were long ago etched into these barren mountain villages.
Islamic culture is like a river winding from deserts, oases, and grasslands. It passed through the ethnic groups of our Northwest, leaving behind clean diets, solemn rituals, and generous hospitality, along with a stubbornness that refuses to retreat easily. I walked through empty valleys and heard young shepherds talk of distant holy lands, their eyes gleaming in the moonlight; inside them was a faith in ultimate justice, an expectation of divine judgment, and a longing for the grievances of this life to be washed away in the next world.
Compared to a culture that finds its return in "The One," Chinese civilization is more like a thick clay accustomed to compromise and harmony, allowing for multiple gods and ancestors to coexist. It permits Confucianism, Buddhism, and Taoism to layer upon each other, allowing ancestral tablets to sit alongside abstract concepts. So when the two meet, tensions inevitably arise at certain points: one emphasizes absolute truth, the other is used to diversity; one emphasizes commandments, the other trusts more in human sentiment. But what I saw on the Northwest Loess Plateau was another scene entirely—the two cultures avoiding direct collision, choosing instead to live quietly side-by-side in daily life.
I still remember those times in the residual snow of Xihaigu when people gathered for the collective visiting of graves. The loess ridge was all white, and people gathered from every direction; white headscarves fluttered in the wind, and the repressed historical memories in their chests were awakened by unified movements and sounds. It was a belief forged through tragic events and the cost of blood, a spiritual history rarely written about head-on in mainstream textbooks. Every major religion in the world has been embroiled in power and violence in some way, but in the daily lives of these grassroots believers, faith acts more like a rope that pulls people out of failure and poverty, allowing them to keep a shred of dignity in extreme hardship.
Crossing the Tianshan Mountains, I heard ballads on the grasslands that blended Islamic and nomadic traditions. Under the vast sky, the stars were cold; human voices blended with drumbeats, and saddles and sandalwood paperweights bore witness to time sinking suffering into the internal textures of the soul. The modern World-Systems theory loves to talk about "center-periphery," placing the Islamic world and many parts of Africa and Latin America at the exploited end, discussing economics, resources, and trade structures. Structurally, these points have merit, but I always feel they can't fully capture the soul of a people.
In that vastness, I felt another confrontation: facing the single-path narrative represented by the West, those civilizations classified as "the periphery" are silently maintaining a different cosmic order with their own scriptures, drumbeats, and desolate graves on the loess soil.
The wind of Western culture has been blowing across the seas and into our continent for a long time.
Books tell me its core is reason, science, the individual, and rights—a whole set of cognitive methods supported by empiricism, laboratories, and mathematical models. As anthropologists lament the disintegration of traditional societies, young people in many places have already learned to use this logic to explain the world: the world can be precisely measured, history can be pushed linearly, and the individual is a self-sufficient unit that can separate from family and the earth, connecting with others solely through contracts and law.
I don't deny the value of these achievements. Modern natural science has liberated many from disease and hunger, peeled back the structure of the universe bit by bit, and stripped away layers of human cognitive bias. Interdisciplinary research in cognitive psychology, cultural neuroscience, and anthropology allows us to see that people in different cultures truly leave traces in their brains regarding their understanding of self, groups, and fairness. These findings help us recognize differences more calmly and stop easily judging entire civilizations as "superior" or "inferior."
The problem arises when this way of explaining the world is absolutized by some, treated as the only yardstick, and the richness of other civilizations is compressed into being "pre-modern" or "backward." World-systems theorists, post-colonial scholars, and researchers of civilizational diversity have spent decades deconstructing this single-line theory. They tell us that Western modernity is also a specific historical path, the result of a specific geography, religion, and economic structure, rather than a universal template that everyone must follow.
Standing on the banks of a river in the North as the ice began to break, I spent a long time thinking about this. As the ice on the river started to shift, water came roaring up from underneath, pushing the jagged chunks aside, and when the sunlight hit it, the surface glistened. In that moment, I knew clearly: if any one culture on this planet claims the title of 'modern' exclusively, leaving no room for other civilizations to speak, that is a dangerous kind of poverty.
Western culture offers a powerful toolkit—scientific methods, institutional design, human rights discourse, and democratic ideals. These are things countries across the globe can selectively borrow to improve their lives, build fairer societies, and protect human dignity. But it cannot, and should not, erase the depth of the Chinese loess plateau, the devotion found in Islamic scriptures, or the rhythm of life in African drumbeats.
When I think of African culture, I’m reminded of a young man I met in the borderlands who had just returned from his studies in Africa. At a snowy outpost, he told me about grasslands beyond the ones I knew—where the grass is greener, the sky is bluer, and cattle and drumbeats interweave by evening campfires. He talked about village elders, market chants, the patterns painted on skin during rituals, and how they navigate between the memory of colonialism and the hope for the future. Anthropologists have long listened to those voices in the forests and the Sahel region of Africa, documenting oral histories, myths, and kinship systems, while reflecting on the arrogance that once used evolutionary theories to hold others down.
For a long time, the true depth of African civilization was misunderstood by the world. Some media outlets only like to focus on war, disease, and poverty as the main themes, occasionally tossing in a shallow nod to 'primitive joy.' This kind of narrative is neither fair nor serious. Later scholarship has begun to correct this, highlighting the complexity of Africa's diverse ethnic groups, languages, and religions, emphasizing the wisdom in oral traditions, and focusing on ethics centered on the collective and a deep sensitivity to natural rhythms.
Behind those words, I always picture another scene I’ve seen on the grasslands of the Northwest: the withering and flourishing of wild grass, the movement of groups, the blending of drumbeats and horse hooves, where people feel as much like dust as they do sparks of fire. The dancing of African people under the scorching sun and the rhythm of their drums aren't so different in spirit from the long, flowing folk songs of our Northern grasslands, the drumbeats of Central Asia, or the dua (supplication/prayer) of the Arab world. They are all humanity’s shared response to the earth, to life, and to death—using the body to remember and rhythm to face an unknowable fate.
Thinking about this amid the heavy snowfall in the Liupan Mountains, a rough map of the human spirit began to unfold in my mind.
Chinese civilization is like a great loess mountain—topped with residual snow, rooted in ancient graves; the legal and ritual codes are like layers of stacked earth, with scriptures buried alongside farming tools. Islamic civilization is like a river flowing from a sea of sand, lingering near the snow line, carrying a strict rhythm that washes away human desires again and again, teaching people to find freedom within discipline. Western civilization is like a machine that is constantly self-deconstructing and reassembling, skilled at looking at itself with skepticism, upgrading its tools, and measuring the world with precision. African culture is like a grassland panting in the heat: the surface is all dance and song, but underneath lies a profound, lingering trauma and resilience, rising again and again after being beaten down, using the rhythm of the body to mend the cracks left by history.
These labels have their limitations, but I’m no longer interested in swapping them for fancier terms. Academia already has too many complex concepts: dialogue of civilizations, multiple modernities, post-colonial context, cultural psychological structures... these words have their place, and I’ve been inspired by them too. But standing at the doorway of a mud house in Xihaigu, watching black goats forage for grass on the edge of the snow above an old cave dwelling, I trust the simplest judgment more—every civilization has tempered its bones in extreme environments and has its own way of upholding human dignity.
The problem isn't the differences themselves; the problem is the arrogance.
The pattern of the world’s mainstream culture isn't a fixed table; it’s a flowing river. The Chinese, Islamic, Western, and African traditions have all been pushed to the center or the margins at different points in history. In our era, technology and capital make information move fast, making some discourses easy to amplify and other voices easy to drown out. The media loves chasing the 'mainstream' label, as if whatever is mentioned most often is the core, while the quiet, the patient, and the remote can be ignored.
Having stood before the abandoned graves in Xihaigu for a long time, another bottom line formed in my heart: what defines a civilization shouldn't be its volume, but how it treats its weakest members. Whether the most marginalized people in a culture—the poor, the sick, minorities, the downtrodden—can still maintain basic dignity and aren't treated as disposable, that is the true litmus test.
Chinese civilization uses patriarchal clans and local community bonds to weave the isolated individual into a network of kinship and geography; even if it’s rudimentary, it provides them with a meal and a place to stand. Islamic doctrine, through almsgiving and communal dua, allows the most impoverished to find their place within the collective. Western rights discourse uses institutions to build defenses for the weak; though imperfect, it at least establishes a standard to hold power publicly accountable. African village traditions use sharing and festivals to let those living through famine and war catch their breath within the rhythm of the group.
None of these approaches are pure; all carry the risk of being co-opted by power or swallowed by the market. Yet, in the wind and snow of the Liupan Mountains, under the dim light of a mud house, in the long winds of the grasslands, and among the drumbeats at the intersection of forest and desert, I still choose to believe in a stubborn, cleansing spirit that appears in different civilizations under different names, resisting the cold tendency to treat human beings as mere tools or numbers.
I walk along the long mountain road, the ground beneath my feet frozen hard, the path ahead rising in segments. Behind me is the heavy memory this land has pressed upon me; in front of me is a world surrounded by all sorts of 'mainstream' terminology.
How to understand the world’s mainstream culture is a question that, for many who call themselves intellectuals, easily becomes a word game. They move concepts around in their studies and rank the superiority of civilizations in lecture halls, talking about tolerance and dialogue while their eyes are often clouded with the arrogance of perspective. I don't want to repeat their path.
I would rather respond in a slower way: walking on the loess mountains, standing by the residual snow in Xihaigu, listening to the night wind in a mud house, touching the damp earth in front of a weathered cave dwelling, and then bringing the theories of distant civilizations, small experimental data, and those so-called cutting-edge theories, one by one, to this place—setting them on the earthen kang (heated brick bed) and beside the lonely graves, just to see how much weight they truly hold.
Perhaps in the end, I will only get some blurry answers:
Chinese civilization teaches me that a person must have a sense of shame; even if you're so poor that all you have left is rags, you must hold onto a bottom line that cannot be sold. Islamic civilization reminds me that there are judgments in this world higher than the pursuit of a livelihood, and beliefs more stable than current power; one should not forget the longing for ultimate justice. Western civilization forces me to learn how to doubt myself, to use the light of reason to illuminate blind faith, to restrain power with institutions, and to reflect on prejudices with science. African culture, meanwhile, helps me remember that the movement of the body and the drumbeat of the collective can carry trauma, that memory isn't just found on paper, and dignity isn't maintained by words alone.
These realizations are rough and unsystematic; they wouldn't hold up in an academic debate. But I am willing to stand by them because they were gained through walking, honed bit by bit in the wind and snow, on the loess soil, and before the residual snow on abandoned graves.
I head back from the snowy road of the Liupan Mountains as twilight approaches. The black goats on the ridge are being herded into their pens, the waning moon hangs higher, and a faint, dim yellow light filters through the cracks in the mud cottage windows. The snow on the old graves grows deeper, the shadows of the crumbling cave dwellings grow darker, and the wind circles the earthen slopes.
The world's mainstream culture is debating in far-off places, shouting slogans in conference halls, on the internet, and on paper. I cannot hear those echoes; I only hear the silence emanating from the ground beneath my feet.
Perhaps one day, when these four winds blow harder, and more children hold books from distant lands in their hands, learning the languages of other places through screens, they will understand the big words—Chinese, Islamic, Western, African—in new ways, finding more precise explanations in new laboratories and fields. I am no longer young, and I won't be around for that final conclusion.
All I can do is write down these feelings from the loess today and pass them on to those younger than me.
When that time comes, if they happen to pass through the Liupan Mountains in the deep snow, walk past the mud houses, and weave between the black goats on the ridge and the snow-covered graves, they might suddenly feel a touch of hesitation: when faced with the glittering mainstream of the distant world, how should one place one's own steps? How to be neither kneeling nor drawing a sword? How to be neither inferior nor blindly arrogant?
If they find themselves stuck with this question, then I will know that this long mountain road was not walked in vain. view all
[Internet Repost]
Standing on the rugged loess soil of the Liupan Mountains, I want to explore the deep-seated barriers in communication between the world’s major civilizations from both historical and contemporary perspectives. By dissecting the divisions caused by cultural centrism and cognitive arrogance, we must call for an open-minded approach grounded in humble listening and mutual respect to foster meaningful dialogue among diverse cultures.
The loess mountains look grim in the morning light, with gully after gully stacked up like faded scripture pages that you want to read but can never quite make out. I’m standing on the shadowed slope of the Liupan Mountains. Beneath my feet is a mountain path polished smooth by snow, and in the distance, the leftover snow still glimmers on the ridges of Xihaigu, a bone-chilling white like an old vow buried deep in the earth that refuses to fade away even in this day and age. A wind blows down from the north, carrying sand, bits of dry grass, and half-heard languages, pushing one far away from the familiar edges of home.
I’ve always felt that certain questions have to be asked at passes like this—in the hours when the wind is howling and the snow is just about to lock everything down—only then can the heart be truly honest. For example, how do we understand the "mainstream cultures" that everyone talks about these days: Chinese, Islamic, Western, or the songs and drumbeats of Africa? Talk about this at a desk, and it sounds greasy; say it while walking on the loess soil, and your tongue feels heavy and the words turn hard.
I’m carrying an old, well-worn backpack filled with scholars' books and a few printed papers with English titles, all discussing how civilization, faith, and the human mind are molded by different cultures. The data in labs is cold, and I always feel a bit of hesitation bringing those charts and curves into these parched loess ravines. But since we live in an age where science is the yardstick, I can't just rely on intuition like I used to, so I have to force these cold graphs and the coarse soil together to see if they can still make a real, honest sound.
The long mountain path stretches forward, flanked by mud houses with walls stained dark brown by years of smoke, and ice hanging from the eaves like rows upon rows of frozen question marks. Black goats on the ridges are scattered among the gravel and melting snow, heads bobbing as they tear dry grass from the ground. A sliver of a moon hangs on the horizon, as grey and white as bone, lingering in the narrow space between the sunlight and the wind.
On mornings like this, I like to imagine the four cultures as four winds blowing from different directions, colliding and tangling on this uneven rock we call the world. Anthropologists have long reminded us that culture isn't a flat map; it's a piece of rugged terrain where multiple highlands rise simultaneously, with different civilizations feeling their way up their own slopes, and no one can take another’s steps for them. It’s just that as history unfolded, it was written as a single line. Many writers took the easy way out, starting the clock on the other side of the distant ocean, then using a thick line to turn the scale of civilization into a rigid ruler, leaving the world measured and broken into scattered pieces.
When I read those books in my youth, I felt anxious. The books depicted Chinese civilization as an ancient and enclosed basin, the Islamic world as a mixture of passion and tradition, and Africans as reduced to songs, tribes, and scars. As for the West, there was only a sense of taken-for-granted affirmation—science, reason, the individual, and rights—as if these words could only naturally describe one region, one skin color. Years later, sitting in the mud houses of Xihaigu, on the Gobi Desert of Xinjiang, or beside the ice-thawed riverbeds of the north, I sifted through those claims over and over, slowly learning to re-examine those high-gloss, preconceived terms against the much harsher reality.
I suspect that only by standing on our own solid earth can these four cultures truly reveal themselves, like four travelers arriving from afar, each carrying their own dust and old wounds, sitting together in a mud cabin where the fire is small, the tea is weak, and no one tries to speak too loudly.
The Loess Plateau speaks first.
The culture of this land doesn't rely on noisy proclamations; it presses its truths beneath the soil, burying memories between desolate graves and residual snow. Scholars love to talk about "civilization types" or the "Axial Age," framing Chinese civilization as a massive entity with a skeleton of texts, rituals, and dynasties, as if all that rolled across this continent was just a political history from the Zhou Dynasty to today. Having spent so much time in the villages, I feel more and more that this view is far too dismissive of the grassroots.
The true roots of China are rarely in temples or stone tablets, but in the dark corners of loess cave dwellings, in the breath exhaled on the edge of a *kang* (heated brick bed) in deep winter, and in the feet of farmers silently stepping into the silt after a flood. Modern scholarship is beginning to shift this way, with sociology and anthropology studies moving their focus from the center to the edges, claiming to rewrite a bottom-up history of China and seeking to understand a society of "relational embeddedness"—where people aren't isolated individuals, but are bound by invisible ropes of kinship, local roots, and integrity. The networks woven by these ropes are thicker than legal clauses and more solid than the discourse of rights.
While these theories circle each other on paper, the loess has already lived them out. The mud houses of Xihaigu, the long paths between mountains, the calloused hands of the farmers, the muffled sighs of women at night—these are all nodes in this network. It defines what it means to be "home," what "human sentiment" is, what "face" is, and what "shame" is. It also answers the question "Who am I?" very specifically—I am the son of this family in this village, a person in this gully, a handful of soil by the ancestral graves.
With Chinese culture so deeply rooted, it naturally has an instinctive reaction to the winds from outside. It is not showy, not easily excited, and its wariness is laced with curiosity, while its curiosity carries a simple self-confidence. For over a century, the winds of the West, Islam, and Africa have all swept across this land. City dwellers quickly learned to use words like "globalization," but the Loess Plateau is more cautious; it first tests the temperature of these winds with its own thick soil. What it can handle, it absorbs and turns into a new layer of itself; winds that blow too fast are made to circle the mountain passes twice and slow down.
On the other side of the Liupan Mountains, I encountered the wind of Islam.
It was a day of heavy snow that sealed the mountains, leaving the ridges of Xihaigu a uniform grey and white. In a mud house in a village, I heard an elder softly reciting scriptures—not in the uniform tone heard in city mosques, but with a local accent, family whispers, long-suppressed frustrations, and a humble sense of pride. The word "Islam" is too vast on a world map; when scholars write about it, they often get stuck in the shadows of politics and violence, rarely lowering their heads to see how ordinary believers maintain their discipline in a desolate life.
The Islam I saw in the loess cave dwellings wasn't some abstract buzzword, but a low-key, disciplined way of life. Washing hands and faces, raising hands for *dua* (supplication/prayer), observing dietary restrictions, holding one's tongue, and when suffering bears down, leaving behind a word of "submission." But that submission isn't surrender to power; it’s a form of finding peace within oneself amidst misery. I later read research in religion and cognitive science suggesting that long-term prayer and collective *masjid* (mosque) worship strengthen brain regions related to communal feeling and order, making it easier for people to experience the existence of a "community" and enhancing unity and endurance in hardship. These differences, visible in cold charts, were long ago etched into these barren mountain villages.
Islamic culture is like a river winding from deserts, oases, and grasslands. It passed through the ethnic groups of our Northwest, leaving behind clean diets, solemn rituals, and generous hospitality, along with a stubbornness that refuses to retreat easily. I walked through empty valleys and heard young shepherds talk of distant holy lands, their eyes gleaming in the moonlight; inside them was a faith in ultimate justice, an expectation of divine judgment, and a longing for the grievances of this life to be washed away in the next world.
Compared to a culture that finds its return in "The One," Chinese civilization is more like a thick clay accustomed to compromise and harmony, allowing for multiple gods and ancestors to coexist. It permits Confucianism, Buddhism, and Taoism to layer upon each other, allowing ancestral tablets to sit alongside abstract concepts. So when the two meet, tensions inevitably arise at certain points: one emphasizes absolute truth, the other is used to diversity; one emphasizes commandments, the other trusts more in human sentiment. But what I saw on the Northwest Loess Plateau was another scene entirely—the two cultures avoiding direct collision, choosing instead to live quietly side-by-side in daily life.
I still remember those times in the residual snow of Xihaigu when people gathered for the collective visiting of graves. The loess ridge was all white, and people gathered from every direction; white headscarves fluttered in the wind, and the repressed historical memories in their chests were awakened by unified movements and sounds. It was a belief forged through tragic events and the cost of blood, a spiritual history rarely written about head-on in mainstream textbooks. Every major religion in the world has been embroiled in power and violence in some way, but in the daily lives of these grassroots believers, faith acts more like a rope that pulls people out of failure and poverty, allowing them to keep a shred of dignity in extreme hardship.
Crossing the Tianshan Mountains, I heard ballads on the grasslands that blended Islamic and nomadic traditions. Under the vast sky, the stars were cold; human voices blended with drumbeats, and saddles and sandalwood paperweights bore witness to time sinking suffering into the internal textures of the soul. The modern World-Systems theory loves to talk about "center-periphery," placing the Islamic world and many parts of Africa and Latin America at the exploited end, discussing economics, resources, and trade structures. Structurally, these points have merit, but I always feel they can't fully capture the soul of a people.
In that vastness, I felt another confrontation: facing the single-path narrative represented by the West, those civilizations classified as "the periphery" are silently maintaining a different cosmic order with their own scriptures, drumbeats, and desolate graves on the loess soil.
The wind of Western culture has been blowing across the seas and into our continent for a long time.
Books tell me its core is reason, science, the individual, and rights—a whole set of cognitive methods supported by empiricism, laboratories, and mathematical models. As anthropologists lament the disintegration of traditional societies, young people in many places have already learned to use this logic to explain the world: the world can be precisely measured, history can be pushed linearly, and the individual is a self-sufficient unit that can separate from family and the earth, connecting with others solely through contracts and law.
I don't deny the value of these achievements. Modern natural science has liberated many from disease and hunger, peeled back the structure of the universe bit by bit, and stripped away layers of human cognitive bias. Interdisciplinary research in cognitive psychology, cultural neuroscience, and anthropology allows us to see that people in different cultures truly leave traces in their brains regarding their understanding of self, groups, and fairness. These findings help us recognize differences more calmly and stop easily judging entire civilizations as "superior" or "inferior."
The problem arises when this way of explaining the world is absolutized by some, treated as the only yardstick, and the richness of other civilizations is compressed into being "pre-modern" or "backward." World-systems theorists, post-colonial scholars, and researchers of civilizational diversity have spent decades deconstructing this single-line theory. They tell us that Western modernity is also a specific historical path, the result of a specific geography, religion, and economic structure, rather than a universal template that everyone must follow.
Standing on the banks of a river in the North as the ice began to break, I spent a long time thinking about this. As the ice on the river started to shift, water came roaring up from underneath, pushing the jagged chunks aside, and when the sunlight hit it, the surface glistened. In that moment, I knew clearly: if any one culture on this planet claims the title of 'modern' exclusively, leaving no room for other civilizations to speak, that is a dangerous kind of poverty.
Western culture offers a powerful toolkit—scientific methods, institutional design, human rights discourse, and democratic ideals. These are things countries across the globe can selectively borrow to improve their lives, build fairer societies, and protect human dignity. But it cannot, and should not, erase the depth of the Chinese loess plateau, the devotion found in Islamic scriptures, or the rhythm of life in African drumbeats.
When I think of African culture, I’m reminded of a young man I met in the borderlands who had just returned from his studies in Africa. At a snowy outpost, he told me about grasslands beyond the ones I knew—where the grass is greener, the sky is bluer, and cattle and drumbeats interweave by evening campfires. He talked about village elders, market chants, the patterns painted on skin during rituals, and how they navigate between the memory of colonialism and the hope for the future. Anthropologists have long listened to those voices in the forests and the Sahel region of Africa, documenting oral histories, myths, and kinship systems, while reflecting on the arrogance that once used evolutionary theories to hold others down.
For a long time, the true depth of African civilization was misunderstood by the world. Some media outlets only like to focus on war, disease, and poverty as the main themes, occasionally tossing in a shallow nod to 'primitive joy.' This kind of narrative is neither fair nor serious. Later scholarship has begun to correct this, highlighting the complexity of Africa's diverse ethnic groups, languages, and religions, emphasizing the wisdom in oral traditions, and focusing on ethics centered on the collective and a deep sensitivity to natural rhythms.
Behind those words, I always picture another scene I’ve seen on the grasslands of the Northwest: the withering and flourishing of wild grass, the movement of groups, the blending of drumbeats and horse hooves, where people feel as much like dust as they do sparks of fire. The dancing of African people under the scorching sun and the rhythm of their drums aren't so different in spirit from the long, flowing folk songs of our Northern grasslands, the drumbeats of Central Asia, or the dua (supplication/prayer) of the Arab world. They are all humanity’s shared response to the earth, to life, and to death—using the body to remember and rhythm to face an unknowable fate.
Thinking about this amid the heavy snowfall in the Liupan Mountains, a rough map of the human spirit began to unfold in my mind.
Chinese civilization is like a great loess mountain—topped with residual snow, rooted in ancient graves; the legal and ritual codes are like layers of stacked earth, with scriptures buried alongside farming tools. Islamic civilization is like a river flowing from a sea of sand, lingering near the snow line, carrying a strict rhythm that washes away human desires again and again, teaching people to find freedom within discipline. Western civilization is like a machine that is constantly self-deconstructing and reassembling, skilled at looking at itself with skepticism, upgrading its tools, and measuring the world with precision. African culture is like a grassland panting in the heat: the surface is all dance and song, but underneath lies a profound, lingering trauma and resilience, rising again and again after being beaten down, using the rhythm of the body to mend the cracks left by history.
These labels have their limitations, but I’m no longer interested in swapping them for fancier terms. Academia already has too many complex concepts: dialogue of civilizations, multiple modernities, post-colonial context, cultural psychological structures... these words have their place, and I’ve been inspired by them too. But standing at the doorway of a mud house in Xihaigu, watching black goats forage for grass on the edge of the snow above an old cave dwelling, I trust the simplest judgment more—every civilization has tempered its bones in extreme environments and has its own way of upholding human dignity.
The problem isn't the differences themselves; the problem is the arrogance.
The pattern of the world’s mainstream culture isn't a fixed table; it’s a flowing river. The Chinese, Islamic, Western, and African traditions have all been pushed to the center or the margins at different points in history. In our era, technology and capital make information move fast, making some discourses easy to amplify and other voices easy to drown out. The media loves chasing the 'mainstream' label, as if whatever is mentioned most often is the core, while the quiet, the patient, and the remote can be ignored.
Having stood before the abandoned graves in Xihaigu for a long time, another bottom line formed in my heart: what defines a civilization shouldn't be its volume, but how it treats its weakest members. Whether the most marginalized people in a culture—the poor, the sick, minorities, the downtrodden—can still maintain basic dignity and aren't treated as disposable, that is the true litmus test.
Chinese civilization uses patriarchal clans and local community bonds to weave the isolated individual into a network of kinship and geography; even if it’s rudimentary, it provides them with a meal and a place to stand. Islamic doctrine, through almsgiving and communal dua, allows the most impoverished to find their place within the collective. Western rights discourse uses institutions to build defenses for the weak; though imperfect, it at least establishes a standard to hold power publicly accountable. African village traditions use sharing and festivals to let those living through famine and war catch their breath within the rhythm of the group.
None of these approaches are pure; all carry the risk of being co-opted by power or swallowed by the market. Yet, in the wind and snow of the Liupan Mountains, under the dim light of a mud house, in the long winds of the grasslands, and among the drumbeats at the intersection of forest and desert, I still choose to believe in a stubborn, cleansing spirit that appears in different civilizations under different names, resisting the cold tendency to treat human beings as mere tools or numbers.
I walk along the long mountain road, the ground beneath my feet frozen hard, the path ahead rising in segments. Behind me is the heavy memory this land has pressed upon me; in front of me is a world surrounded by all sorts of 'mainstream' terminology.
How to understand the world’s mainstream culture is a question that, for many who call themselves intellectuals, easily becomes a word game. They move concepts around in their studies and rank the superiority of civilizations in lecture halls, talking about tolerance and dialogue while their eyes are often clouded with the arrogance of perspective. I don't want to repeat their path.
I would rather respond in a slower way: walking on the loess mountains, standing by the residual snow in Xihaigu, listening to the night wind in a mud house, touching the damp earth in front of a weathered cave dwelling, and then bringing the theories of distant civilizations, small experimental data, and those so-called cutting-edge theories, one by one, to this place—setting them on the earthen kang (heated brick bed) and beside the lonely graves, just to see how much weight they truly hold.
Perhaps in the end, I will only get some blurry answers:
Chinese civilization teaches me that a person must have a sense of shame; even if you're so poor that all you have left is rags, you must hold onto a bottom line that cannot be sold. Islamic civilization reminds me that there are judgments in this world higher than the pursuit of a livelihood, and beliefs more stable than current power; one should not forget the longing for ultimate justice. Western civilization forces me to learn how to doubt myself, to use the light of reason to illuminate blind faith, to restrain power with institutions, and to reflect on prejudices with science. African culture, meanwhile, helps me remember that the movement of the body and the drumbeat of the collective can carry trauma, that memory isn't just found on paper, and dignity isn't maintained by words alone.
These realizations are rough and unsystematic; they wouldn't hold up in an academic debate. But I am willing to stand by them because they were gained through walking, honed bit by bit in the wind and snow, on the loess soil, and before the residual snow on abandoned graves.
I head back from the snowy road of the Liupan Mountains as twilight approaches. The black goats on the ridge are being herded into their pens, the waning moon hangs higher, and a faint, dim yellow light filters through the cracks in the mud cottage windows. The snow on the old graves grows deeper, the shadows of the crumbling cave dwellings grow darker, and the wind circles the earthen slopes.
The world's mainstream culture is debating in far-off places, shouting slogans in conference halls, on the internet, and on paper. I cannot hear those echoes; I only hear the silence emanating from the ground beneath my feet.
Perhaps one day, when these four winds blow harder, and more children hold books from distant lands in their hands, learning the languages of other places through screens, they will understand the big words—Chinese, Islamic, Western, African—in new ways, finding more precise explanations in new laboratories and fields. I am no longer young, and I won't be around for that final conclusion.
All I can do is write down these feelings from the loess today and pass them on to those younger than me.
When that time comes, if they happen to pass through the Liupan Mountains in the deep snow, walk past the mud houses, and weave between the black goats on the ridge and the snow-covered graves, they might suddenly feel a touch of hesitation: when faced with the glittering mainstream of the distant world, how should one place one's own steps? How to be neither kneeling nor drawing a sword? How to be neither inferior nor blindly arrogant?
If they find themselves stuck with this question, then I will know that this long mountain road was not walked in vain.
Standing on the rugged loess soil of the Liupan Mountains, I want to explore the deep-seated barriers in communication between the world’s major civilizations from both historical and contemporary perspectives. By dissecting the divisions caused by cultural centrism and cognitive arrogance, we must call for an open-minded approach grounded in humble listening and mutual respect to foster meaningful dialogue among diverse cultures.
The loess mountains look grim in the morning light, with gully after gully stacked up like faded scripture pages that you want to read but can never quite make out. I’m standing on the shadowed slope of the Liupan Mountains. Beneath my feet is a mountain path polished smooth by snow, and in the distance, the leftover snow still glimmers on the ridges of Xihaigu, a bone-chilling white like an old vow buried deep in the earth that refuses to fade away even in this day and age. A wind blows down from the north, carrying sand, bits of dry grass, and half-heard languages, pushing one far away from the familiar edges of home.
I’ve always felt that certain questions have to be asked at passes like this—in the hours when the wind is howling and the snow is just about to lock everything down—only then can the heart be truly honest. For example, how do we understand the "mainstream cultures" that everyone talks about these days: Chinese, Islamic, Western, or the songs and drumbeats of Africa? Talk about this at a desk, and it sounds greasy; say it while walking on the loess soil, and your tongue feels heavy and the words turn hard.
I’m carrying an old, well-worn backpack filled with scholars' books and a few printed papers with English titles, all discussing how civilization, faith, and the human mind are molded by different cultures. The data in labs is cold, and I always feel a bit of hesitation bringing those charts and curves into these parched loess ravines. But since we live in an age where science is the yardstick, I can't just rely on intuition like I used to, so I have to force these cold graphs and the coarse soil together to see if they can still make a real, honest sound.
The long mountain path stretches forward, flanked by mud houses with walls stained dark brown by years of smoke, and ice hanging from the eaves like rows upon rows of frozen question marks. Black goats on the ridges are scattered among the gravel and melting snow, heads bobbing as they tear dry grass from the ground. A sliver of a moon hangs on the horizon, as grey and white as bone, lingering in the narrow space between the sunlight and the wind.
On mornings like this, I like to imagine the four cultures as four winds blowing from different directions, colliding and tangling on this uneven rock we call the world. Anthropologists have long reminded us that culture isn't a flat map; it's a piece of rugged terrain where multiple highlands rise simultaneously, with different civilizations feeling their way up their own slopes, and no one can take another’s steps for them. It’s just that as history unfolded, it was written as a single line. Many writers took the easy way out, starting the clock on the other side of the distant ocean, then using a thick line to turn the scale of civilization into a rigid ruler, leaving the world measured and broken into scattered pieces.
When I read those books in my youth, I felt anxious. The books depicted Chinese civilization as an ancient and enclosed basin, the Islamic world as a mixture of passion and tradition, and Africans as reduced to songs, tribes, and scars. As for the West, there was only a sense of taken-for-granted affirmation—science, reason, the individual, and rights—as if these words could only naturally describe one region, one skin color. Years later, sitting in the mud houses of Xihaigu, on the Gobi Desert of Xinjiang, or beside the ice-thawed riverbeds of the north, I sifted through those claims over and over, slowly learning to re-examine those high-gloss, preconceived terms against the much harsher reality.
I suspect that only by standing on our own solid earth can these four cultures truly reveal themselves, like four travelers arriving from afar, each carrying their own dust and old wounds, sitting together in a mud cabin where the fire is small, the tea is weak, and no one tries to speak too loudly.
The Loess Plateau speaks first.
The culture of this land doesn't rely on noisy proclamations; it presses its truths beneath the soil, burying memories between desolate graves and residual snow. Scholars love to talk about "civilization types" or the "Axial Age," framing Chinese civilization as a massive entity with a skeleton of texts, rituals, and dynasties, as if all that rolled across this continent was just a political history from the Zhou Dynasty to today. Having spent so much time in the villages, I feel more and more that this view is far too dismissive of the grassroots.
The true roots of China are rarely in temples or stone tablets, but in the dark corners of loess cave dwellings, in the breath exhaled on the edge of a *kang* (heated brick bed) in deep winter, and in the feet of farmers silently stepping into the silt after a flood. Modern scholarship is beginning to shift this way, with sociology and anthropology studies moving their focus from the center to the edges, claiming to rewrite a bottom-up history of China and seeking to understand a society of "relational embeddedness"—where people aren't isolated individuals, but are bound by invisible ropes of kinship, local roots, and integrity. The networks woven by these ropes are thicker than legal clauses and more solid than the discourse of rights.
While these theories circle each other on paper, the loess has already lived them out. The mud houses of Xihaigu, the long paths between mountains, the calloused hands of the farmers, the muffled sighs of women at night—these are all nodes in this network. It defines what it means to be "home," what "human sentiment" is, what "face" is, and what "shame" is. It also answers the question "Who am I?" very specifically—I am the son of this family in this village, a person in this gully, a handful of soil by the ancestral graves.
With Chinese culture so deeply rooted, it naturally has an instinctive reaction to the winds from outside. It is not showy, not easily excited, and its wariness is laced with curiosity, while its curiosity carries a simple self-confidence. For over a century, the winds of the West, Islam, and Africa have all swept across this land. City dwellers quickly learned to use words like "globalization," but the Loess Plateau is more cautious; it first tests the temperature of these winds with its own thick soil. What it can handle, it absorbs and turns into a new layer of itself; winds that blow too fast are made to circle the mountain passes twice and slow down.
On the other side of the Liupan Mountains, I encountered the wind of Islam.
It was a day of heavy snow that sealed the mountains, leaving the ridges of Xihaigu a uniform grey and white. In a mud house in a village, I heard an elder softly reciting scriptures—not in the uniform tone heard in city mosques, but with a local accent, family whispers, long-suppressed frustrations, and a humble sense of pride. The word "Islam" is too vast on a world map; when scholars write about it, they often get stuck in the shadows of politics and violence, rarely lowering their heads to see how ordinary believers maintain their discipline in a desolate life.
The Islam I saw in the loess cave dwellings wasn't some abstract buzzword, but a low-key, disciplined way of life. Washing hands and faces, raising hands for *dua* (supplication/prayer), observing dietary restrictions, holding one's tongue, and when suffering bears down, leaving behind a word of "submission." But that submission isn't surrender to power; it’s a form of finding peace within oneself amidst misery. I later read research in religion and cognitive science suggesting that long-term prayer and collective *masjid* (mosque) worship strengthen brain regions related to communal feeling and order, making it easier for people to experience the existence of a "community" and enhancing unity and endurance in hardship. These differences, visible in cold charts, were long ago etched into these barren mountain villages.
Islamic culture is like a river winding from deserts, oases, and grasslands. It passed through the ethnic groups of our Northwest, leaving behind clean diets, solemn rituals, and generous hospitality, along with a stubbornness that refuses to retreat easily. I walked through empty valleys and heard young shepherds talk of distant holy lands, their eyes gleaming in the moonlight; inside them was a faith in ultimate justice, an expectation of divine judgment, and a longing for the grievances of this life to be washed away in the next world.
Compared to a culture that finds its return in "The One," Chinese civilization is more like a thick clay accustomed to compromise and harmony, allowing for multiple gods and ancestors to coexist. It permits Confucianism, Buddhism, and Taoism to layer upon each other, allowing ancestral tablets to sit alongside abstract concepts. So when the two meet, tensions inevitably arise at certain points: one emphasizes absolute truth, the other is used to diversity; one emphasizes commandments, the other trusts more in human sentiment. But what I saw on the Northwest Loess Plateau was another scene entirely—the two cultures avoiding direct collision, choosing instead to live quietly side-by-side in daily life.
I still remember those times in the residual snow of Xihaigu when people gathered for the collective visiting of graves. The loess ridge was all white, and people gathered from every direction; white headscarves fluttered in the wind, and the repressed historical memories in their chests were awakened by unified movements and sounds. It was a belief forged through tragic events and the cost of blood, a spiritual history rarely written about head-on in mainstream textbooks. Every major religion in the world has been embroiled in power and violence in some way, but in the daily lives of these grassroots believers, faith acts more like a rope that pulls people out of failure and poverty, allowing them to keep a shred of dignity in extreme hardship.
Crossing the Tianshan Mountains, I heard ballads on the grasslands that blended Islamic and nomadic traditions. Under the vast sky, the stars were cold; human voices blended with drumbeats, and saddles and sandalwood paperweights bore witness to time sinking suffering into the internal textures of the soul. The modern World-Systems theory loves to talk about "center-periphery," placing the Islamic world and many parts of Africa and Latin America at the exploited end, discussing economics, resources, and trade structures. Structurally, these points have merit, but I always feel they can't fully capture the soul of a people.
In that vastness, I felt another confrontation: facing the single-path narrative represented by the West, those civilizations classified as "the periphery" are silently maintaining a different cosmic order with their own scriptures, drumbeats, and desolate graves on the loess soil.
The wind of Western culture has been blowing across the seas and into our continent for a long time.
Books tell me its core is reason, science, the individual, and rights—a whole set of cognitive methods supported by empiricism, laboratories, and mathematical models. As anthropologists lament the disintegration of traditional societies, young people in many places have already learned to use this logic to explain the world: the world can be precisely measured, history can be pushed linearly, and the individual is a self-sufficient unit that can separate from family and the earth, connecting with others solely through contracts and law.
I don't deny the value of these achievements. Modern natural science has liberated many from disease and hunger, peeled back the structure of the universe bit by bit, and stripped away layers of human cognitive bias. Interdisciplinary research in cognitive psychology, cultural neuroscience, and anthropology allows us to see that people in different cultures truly leave traces in their brains regarding their understanding of self, groups, and fairness. These findings help us recognize differences more calmly and stop easily judging entire civilizations as "superior" or "inferior."
The problem arises when this way of explaining the world is absolutized by some, treated as the only yardstick, and the richness of other civilizations is compressed into being "pre-modern" or "backward." World-systems theorists, post-colonial scholars, and researchers of civilizational diversity have spent decades deconstructing this single-line theory. They tell us that Western modernity is also a specific historical path, the result of a specific geography, religion, and economic structure, rather than a universal template that everyone must follow.
Standing on the banks of a river in the North as the ice began to break, I spent a long time thinking about this. As the ice on the river started to shift, water came roaring up from underneath, pushing the jagged chunks aside, and when the sunlight hit it, the surface glistened. In that moment, I knew clearly: if any one culture on this planet claims the title of 'modern' exclusively, leaving no room for other civilizations to speak, that is a dangerous kind of poverty.
Western culture offers a powerful toolkit—scientific methods, institutional design, human rights discourse, and democratic ideals. These are things countries across the globe can selectively borrow to improve their lives, build fairer societies, and protect human dignity. But it cannot, and should not, erase the depth of the Chinese loess plateau, the devotion found in Islamic scriptures, or the rhythm of life in African drumbeats.
When I think of African culture, I’m reminded of a young man I met in the borderlands who had just returned from his studies in Africa. At a snowy outpost, he told me about grasslands beyond the ones I knew—where the grass is greener, the sky is bluer, and cattle and drumbeats interweave by evening campfires. He talked about village elders, market chants, the patterns painted on skin during rituals, and how they navigate between the memory of colonialism and the hope for the future. Anthropologists have long listened to those voices in the forests and the Sahel region of Africa, documenting oral histories, myths, and kinship systems, while reflecting on the arrogance that once used evolutionary theories to hold others down.
For a long time, the true depth of African civilization was misunderstood by the world. Some media outlets only like to focus on war, disease, and poverty as the main themes, occasionally tossing in a shallow nod to 'primitive joy.' This kind of narrative is neither fair nor serious. Later scholarship has begun to correct this, highlighting the complexity of Africa's diverse ethnic groups, languages, and religions, emphasizing the wisdom in oral traditions, and focusing on ethics centered on the collective and a deep sensitivity to natural rhythms.
Behind those words, I always picture another scene I’ve seen on the grasslands of the Northwest: the withering and flourishing of wild grass, the movement of groups, the blending of drumbeats and horse hooves, where people feel as much like dust as they do sparks of fire. The dancing of African people under the scorching sun and the rhythm of their drums aren't so different in spirit from the long, flowing folk songs of our Northern grasslands, the drumbeats of Central Asia, or the dua (supplication/prayer) of the Arab world. They are all humanity’s shared response to the earth, to life, and to death—using the body to remember and rhythm to face an unknowable fate.
Thinking about this amid the heavy snowfall in the Liupan Mountains, a rough map of the human spirit began to unfold in my mind.
Chinese civilization is like a great loess mountain—topped with residual snow, rooted in ancient graves; the legal and ritual codes are like layers of stacked earth, with scriptures buried alongside farming tools. Islamic civilization is like a river flowing from a sea of sand, lingering near the snow line, carrying a strict rhythm that washes away human desires again and again, teaching people to find freedom within discipline. Western civilization is like a machine that is constantly self-deconstructing and reassembling, skilled at looking at itself with skepticism, upgrading its tools, and measuring the world with precision. African culture is like a grassland panting in the heat: the surface is all dance and song, but underneath lies a profound, lingering trauma and resilience, rising again and again after being beaten down, using the rhythm of the body to mend the cracks left by history.
These labels have their limitations, but I’m no longer interested in swapping them for fancier terms. Academia already has too many complex concepts: dialogue of civilizations, multiple modernities, post-colonial context, cultural psychological structures... these words have their place, and I’ve been inspired by them too. But standing at the doorway of a mud house in Xihaigu, watching black goats forage for grass on the edge of the snow above an old cave dwelling, I trust the simplest judgment more—every civilization has tempered its bones in extreme environments and has its own way of upholding human dignity.
The problem isn't the differences themselves; the problem is the arrogance.
The pattern of the world’s mainstream culture isn't a fixed table; it’s a flowing river. The Chinese, Islamic, Western, and African traditions have all been pushed to the center or the margins at different points in history. In our era, technology and capital make information move fast, making some discourses easy to amplify and other voices easy to drown out. The media loves chasing the 'mainstream' label, as if whatever is mentioned most often is the core, while the quiet, the patient, and the remote can be ignored.
Having stood before the abandoned graves in Xihaigu for a long time, another bottom line formed in my heart: what defines a civilization shouldn't be its volume, but how it treats its weakest members. Whether the most marginalized people in a culture—the poor, the sick, minorities, the downtrodden—can still maintain basic dignity and aren't treated as disposable, that is the true litmus test.
Chinese civilization uses patriarchal clans and local community bonds to weave the isolated individual into a network of kinship and geography; even if it’s rudimentary, it provides them with a meal and a place to stand. Islamic doctrine, through almsgiving and communal dua, allows the most impoverished to find their place within the collective. Western rights discourse uses institutions to build defenses for the weak; though imperfect, it at least establishes a standard to hold power publicly accountable. African village traditions use sharing and festivals to let those living through famine and war catch their breath within the rhythm of the group.
None of these approaches are pure; all carry the risk of being co-opted by power or swallowed by the market. Yet, in the wind and snow of the Liupan Mountains, under the dim light of a mud house, in the long winds of the grasslands, and among the drumbeats at the intersection of forest and desert, I still choose to believe in a stubborn, cleansing spirit that appears in different civilizations under different names, resisting the cold tendency to treat human beings as mere tools or numbers.
I walk along the long mountain road, the ground beneath my feet frozen hard, the path ahead rising in segments. Behind me is the heavy memory this land has pressed upon me; in front of me is a world surrounded by all sorts of 'mainstream' terminology.
How to understand the world’s mainstream culture is a question that, for many who call themselves intellectuals, easily becomes a word game. They move concepts around in their studies and rank the superiority of civilizations in lecture halls, talking about tolerance and dialogue while their eyes are often clouded with the arrogance of perspective. I don't want to repeat their path.
I would rather respond in a slower way: walking on the loess mountains, standing by the residual snow in Xihaigu, listening to the night wind in a mud house, touching the damp earth in front of a weathered cave dwelling, and then bringing the theories of distant civilizations, small experimental data, and those so-called cutting-edge theories, one by one, to this place—setting them on the earthen kang (heated brick bed) and beside the lonely graves, just to see how much weight they truly hold.
Perhaps in the end, I will only get some blurry answers:
Chinese civilization teaches me that a person must have a sense of shame; even if you're so poor that all you have left is rags, you must hold onto a bottom line that cannot be sold. Islamic civilization reminds me that there are judgments in this world higher than the pursuit of a livelihood, and beliefs more stable than current power; one should not forget the longing for ultimate justice. Western civilization forces me to learn how to doubt myself, to use the light of reason to illuminate blind faith, to restrain power with institutions, and to reflect on prejudices with science. African culture, meanwhile, helps me remember that the movement of the body and the drumbeat of the collective can carry trauma, that memory isn't just found on paper, and dignity isn't maintained by words alone.
These realizations are rough and unsystematic; they wouldn't hold up in an academic debate. But I am willing to stand by them because they were gained through walking, honed bit by bit in the wind and snow, on the loess soil, and before the residual snow on abandoned graves.
I head back from the snowy road of the Liupan Mountains as twilight approaches. The black goats on the ridge are being herded into their pens, the waning moon hangs higher, and a faint, dim yellow light filters through the cracks in the mud cottage windows. The snow on the old graves grows deeper, the shadows of the crumbling cave dwellings grow darker, and the wind circles the earthen slopes.
The world's mainstream culture is debating in far-off places, shouting slogans in conference halls, on the internet, and on paper. I cannot hear those echoes; I only hear the silence emanating from the ground beneath my feet.
Perhaps one day, when these four winds blow harder, and more children hold books from distant lands in their hands, learning the languages of other places through screens, they will understand the big words—Chinese, Islamic, Western, African—in new ways, finding more precise explanations in new laboratories and fields. I am no longer young, and I won't be around for that final conclusion.
All I can do is write down these feelings from the loess today and pass them on to those younger than me.
When that time comes, if they happen to pass through the Liupan Mountains in the deep snow, walk past the mud houses, and weave between the black goats on the ridge and the snow-covered graves, they might suddenly feel a touch of hesitation: when faced with the glittering mainstream of the distant world, how should one place one's own steps? How to be neither kneeling nor drawing a sword? How to be neither inferior nor blindly arrogant?
If they find themselves stuck with this question, then I will know that this long mountain road was not walked in vain.
Understanding Global Civilizations: Breaking Down Arrogance and Cultural Biases in Human History
Articles • Hasan09 posted the article • 0 comments • 32 views • 2026-11-09 10:56
[Internet Repost]
Standing on the rugged loess soil of the Liupan Mountains, I want to explore the deep-seated barriers in communication between the world’s major civilizations from both historical and contemporary perspectives. By dissecting the divisions caused by cultural centrism and cognitive arrogance, we must call for an open-minded approach grounded in humble listening and mutual respect to foster meaningful dialogue among diverse cultures.
The loess mountains look grim in the morning light, with gully after gully stacked up like faded scripture pages that you want to read but can never quite make out. I’m standing on the shadowed slope of the Liupan Mountains. Beneath my feet is a mountain path polished smooth by snow, and in the distance, the leftover snow still glimmers on the ridges of Xihaigu, a bone-chilling white like an old vow buried deep in the earth that refuses to fade away even in this day and age. A wind blows down from the north, carrying sand, bits of dry grass, and half-heard languages, pushing one far away from the familiar edges of home.
I’ve always felt that certain questions have to be asked at passes like this—in the hours when the wind is howling and the snow is just about to lock everything down—only then can the heart be truly honest. For example, how do we understand the "mainstream cultures" that everyone talks about these days: Chinese, Islamic, Western, or the songs and drumbeats of Africa? Talk about this at a desk, and it sounds greasy; say it while walking on the loess soil, and your tongue feels heavy and the words turn hard.
I’m carrying an old, well-worn backpack filled with scholars' books and a few printed papers with English titles, all discussing how civilization, faith, and the human mind are molded by different cultures. The data in labs is cold, and I always feel a bit of hesitation bringing those charts and curves into these parched loess ravines. But since we live in an age where science is the yardstick, I can't just rely on intuition like I used to, so I have to force these cold graphs and the coarse soil together to see if they can still make a real, honest sound.
The long mountain path stretches forward, flanked by mud houses with walls stained dark brown by years of smoke, and ice hanging from the eaves like rows upon rows of frozen question marks. Black goats on the ridges are scattered among the gravel and melting snow, heads bobbing as they tear dry grass from the ground. A sliver of a moon hangs on the horizon, as grey and white as bone, lingering in the narrow space between the sunlight and the wind.
On mornings like this, I like to imagine the four cultures as four winds blowing from different directions, colliding and tangling on this uneven rock we call the world. Anthropologists have long reminded us that culture isn't a flat map; it's a piece of rugged terrain where multiple highlands rise simultaneously, with different civilizations feeling their way up their own slopes, and no one can take another’s steps for them. It’s just that as history unfolded, it was written as a single line. Many writers took the easy way out, starting the clock on the other side of the distant ocean, then using a thick line to turn the scale of civilization into a rigid ruler, leaving the world measured and broken into scattered pieces.
When I read those books in my youth, I felt anxious. The books depicted Chinese civilization as an ancient and enclosed basin, the Islamic world as a mixture of passion and tradition, and Africans as reduced to songs, tribes, and scars. As for the West, there was only a sense of taken-for-granted affirmation—science, reason, the individual, and rights—as if these words could only naturally describe one region, one skin color. Years later, sitting in the mud houses of Xihaigu, on the Gobi Desert of Xinjiang, or beside the ice-thawed riverbeds of the north, I sifted through those claims over and over, slowly learning to re-examine those high-gloss, preconceived terms against the much harsher reality.
I suspect that only by standing on our own solid earth can these four cultures truly reveal themselves, like four travelers arriving from afar, each carrying their own dust and old wounds, sitting together in a mud cabin where the fire is small, the tea is weak, and no one tries to speak too loudly.
The Loess Plateau speaks first.
The culture of this land doesn't rely on noisy proclamations; it presses its truths beneath the soil, burying memories between desolate graves and residual snow. Scholars love to talk about "civilization types" or the "Axial Age," framing Chinese civilization as a massive entity with a skeleton of texts, rituals, and dynasties, as if all that rolled across this continent was just a political history from the Zhou Dynasty to today. Having spent so much time in the villages, I feel more and more that this view is far too dismissive of the grassroots.
The true roots of China are rarely in temples or stone tablets, but in the dark corners of loess cave dwellings, in the breath exhaled on the edge of a *kang* (heated brick bed) in deep winter, and in the feet of farmers silently stepping into the silt after a flood. Modern scholarship is beginning to shift this way, with sociology and anthropology studies moving their focus from the center to the edges, claiming to rewrite a bottom-up history of China and seeking to understand a society of "relational embeddedness"—where people aren't isolated individuals, but are bound by invisible ropes of kinship, local roots, and integrity. The networks woven by these ropes are thicker than legal clauses and more solid than the discourse of rights.
While these theories circle each other on paper, the loess has already lived them out. The mud houses of Xihaigu, the long paths between mountains, the calloused hands of the farmers, the muffled sighs of women at night—these are all nodes in this network. It defines what it means to be "home," what "human sentiment" is, what "face" is, and what "shame" is. It also answers the question "Who am I?" very specifically—I am the son of this family in this village, a person in this gully, a handful of soil by the ancestral graves.
With Chinese culture so deeply rooted, it naturally has an instinctive reaction to the winds from outside. It is not showy, not easily excited, and its wariness is laced with curiosity, while its curiosity carries a simple self-confidence. For over a century, the winds of the West, Islam, and Africa have all swept across this land. City dwellers quickly learned to use words like "globalization," but the Loess Plateau is more cautious; it first tests the temperature of these winds with its own thick soil. What it can handle, it absorbs and turns into a new layer of itself; winds that blow too fast are made to circle the mountain passes twice and slow down.
On the other side of the Liupan Mountains, I encountered the wind of Islam.
It was a day of heavy snow that sealed the mountains, leaving the ridges of Xihaigu a uniform grey and white. In a mud house in a village, I heard an elder softly reciting scriptures—not in the uniform tone heard in city mosques, but with a local accent, family whispers, long-suppressed frustrations, and a humble sense of pride. The word "Islam" is too vast on a world map; when scholars write about it, they often get stuck in the shadows of politics and violence, rarely lowering their heads to see how ordinary believers maintain their discipline in a desolate life.
The Islam I saw in the loess cave dwellings wasn't some abstract buzzword, but a low-key, disciplined way of life. Washing hands and faces, raising hands for *dua* (supplication/prayer), observing dietary restrictions, holding one's tongue, and when suffering bears down, leaving behind a word of "submission." But that submission isn't surrender to power; it’s a form of finding peace within oneself amidst misery. I later read research in religion and cognitive science suggesting that long-term prayer and collective *masjid* (mosque) worship strengthen brain regions related to communal feeling and order, making it easier for people to experience the existence of a "community" and enhancing unity and endurance in hardship. These differences, visible in cold charts, were long ago etched into these barren mountain villages.
Islamic culture is like a river winding from deserts, oases, and grasslands. It passed through the ethnic groups of our Northwest, leaving behind clean diets, solemn rituals, and generous hospitality, along with a stubbornness that refuses to retreat easily. I walked through empty valleys and heard young shepherds talk of distant holy lands, their eyes gleaming in the moonlight; inside them was a faith in ultimate justice, an expectation of divine judgment, and a longing for the grievances of this life to be washed away in the next world.
Compared to a culture that finds its return in "The One," Chinese civilization is more like a thick clay accustomed to compromise and harmony, allowing for multiple gods and ancestors to coexist. It permits Confucianism, Buddhism, and Taoism to layer upon each other, allowing ancestral tablets to sit alongside abstract concepts. So when the two meet, tensions inevitably arise at certain points: one emphasizes absolute truth, the other is used to diversity; one emphasizes commandments, the other trusts more in human sentiment. But what I saw on the Northwest Loess Plateau was another scene entirely—the two cultures avoiding direct collision, choosing instead to live quietly side-by-side in daily life.
I still remember those times in the residual snow of Xihaigu when people gathered for the collective visiting of graves. The loess ridge was all white, and people gathered from every direction; white headscarves fluttered in the wind, and the repressed historical memories in their chests were awakened by unified movements and sounds. It was a belief forged through tragic events and the cost of blood, a spiritual history rarely written about head-on in mainstream textbooks. Every major religion in the world has been embroiled in power and violence in some way, but in the daily lives of these grassroots believers, faith acts more like a rope that pulls people out of failure and poverty, allowing them to keep a shred of dignity in extreme hardship.
Crossing the Tianshan Mountains, I heard ballads on the grasslands that blended Islamic and nomadic traditions. Under the vast sky, the stars were cold; human voices blended with drumbeats, and saddles and sandalwood paperweights bore witness to time sinking suffering into the internal textures of the soul. The modern World-Systems theory loves to talk about "center-periphery," placing the Islamic world and many parts of Africa and Latin America at the exploited end, discussing economics, resources, and trade structures. Structurally, these points have merit, but I always feel they can't fully capture the soul of a people.
In that vastness, I felt another confrontation: facing the single-path narrative represented by the West, those civilizations classified as "the periphery" are silently maintaining a different cosmic order with their own scriptures, drumbeats, and desolate graves on the loess soil.
The wind of Western culture has been blowing across the seas and into our continent for a long time.
Books tell me its core is reason, science, the individual, and rights—a whole set of cognitive methods supported by empiricism, laboratories, and mathematical models. As anthropologists lament the disintegration of traditional societies, young people in many places have already learned to use this logic to explain the world: the world can be precisely measured, history can be pushed linearly, and the individual is a self-sufficient unit that can separate from family and the earth, connecting with others solely through contracts and law.
I don't deny the value of these achievements. Modern natural science has liberated many from disease and hunger, peeled back the structure of the universe bit by bit, and stripped away layers of human cognitive bias. Interdisciplinary research in cognitive psychology, cultural neuroscience, and anthropology allows us to see that people in different cultures truly leave traces in their brains regarding their understanding of self, groups, and fairness. These findings help us recognize differences more calmly and stop easily judging entire civilizations as "superior" or "inferior."
The problem arises when this way of explaining the world is absolutized by some, treated as the only yardstick, and the richness of other civilizations is compressed into being "pre-modern" or "backward." World-systems theorists, post-colonial scholars, and researchers of civilizational diversity have spent decades deconstructing this single-line theory. They tell us that Western modernity is also a specific historical path, the result of a specific geography, religion, and economic structure, rather than a universal template that everyone must follow.
Standing on the banks of a river in the North as the ice began to break, I spent a long time thinking about this. As the ice on the river started to shift, water came roaring up from underneath, pushing the jagged chunks aside, and when the sunlight hit it, the surface glistened. In that moment, I knew clearly: if any one culture on this planet claims the title of 'modern' exclusively, leaving no room for other civilizations to speak, that is a dangerous kind of poverty.
Western culture offers a powerful toolkit—scientific methods, institutional design, human rights discourse, and democratic ideals. These are things countries across the globe can selectively borrow to improve their lives, build fairer societies, and protect human dignity. But it cannot, and should not, erase the depth of the Chinese loess plateau, the devotion found in Islamic scriptures, or the rhythm of life in African drumbeats.
When I think of African culture, I’m reminded of a young man I met in the borderlands who had just returned from his studies in Africa. At a snowy outpost, he told me about grasslands beyond the ones I knew—where the grass is greener, the sky is bluer, and cattle and drumbeats interweave by evening campfires. He talked about village elders, market chants, the patterns painted on skin during rituals, and how they navigate between the memory of colonialism and the hope for the future. Anthropologists have long listened to those voices in the forests and the Sahel region of Africa, documenting oral histories, myths, and kinship systems, while reflecting on the arrogance that once used evolutionary theories to hold others down.
For a long time, the true depth of African civilization was misunderstood by the world. Some media outlets only like to focus on war, disease, and poverty as the main themes, occasionally tossing in a shallow nod to 'primitive joy.' This kind of narrative is neither fair nor serious. Later scholarship has begun to correct this, highlighting the complexity of Africa's diverse ethnic groups, languages, and religions, emphasizing the wisdom in oral traditions, and focusing on ethics centered on the collective and a deep sensitivity to natural rhythms.
Behind those words, I always picture another scene I’ve seen on the grasslands of the Northwest: the withering and flourishing of wild grass, the movement of groups, the blending of drumbeats and horse hooves, where people feel as much like dust as they do sparks of fire. The dancing of African people under the scorching sun and the rhythm of their drums aren't so different in spirit from the long, flowing folk songs of our Northern grasslands, the drumbeats of Central Asia, or the dua (supplication/prayer) of the Arab world. They are all humanity’s shared response to the earth, to life, and to death—using the body to remember and rhythm to face an unknowable fate.
Thinking about this amid the heavy snowfall in the Liupan Mountains, a rough map of the human spirit began to unfold in my mind.
Chinese civilization is like a great loess mountain—topped with residual snow, rooted in ancient graves; the legal and ritual codes are like layers of stacked earth, with scriptures buried alongside farming tools. Islamic civilization is like a river flowing from a sea of sand, lingering near the snow line, carrying a strict rhythm that washes away human desires again and again, teaching people to find freedom within discipline. Western civilization is like a machine that is constantly self-deconstructing and reassembling, skilled at looking at itself with skepticism, upgrading its tools, and measuring the world with precision. African culture is like a grassland panting in the heat: the surface is all dance and song, but underneath lies a profound, lingering trauma and resilience, rising again and again after being beaten down, using the rhythm of the body to mend the cracks left by history.
These labels have their limitations, but I’m no longer interested in swapping them for fancier terms. Academia already has too many complex concepts: dialogue of civilizations, multiple modernities, post-colonial context, cultural psychological structures... these words have their place, and I’ve been inspired by them too. But standing at the doorway of a mud house in Xihaigu, watching black goats forage for grass on the edge of the snow above an old cave dwelling, I trust the simplest judgment more—every civilization has tempered its bones in extreme environments and has its own way of upholding human dignity.
The problem isn't the differences themselves; the problem is the arrogance.
The pattern of the world’s mainstream culture isn't a fixed table; it’s a flowing river. The Chinese, Islamic, Western, and African traditions have all been pushed to the center or the margins at different points in history. In our era, technology and capital make information move fast, making some discourses easy to amplify and other voices easy to drown out. The media loves chasing the 'mainstream' label, as if whatever is mentioned most often is the core, while the quiet, the patient, and the remote can be ignored.
Having stood before the abandoned graves in Xihaigu for a long time, another bottom line formed in my heart: what defines a civilization shouldn't be its volume, but how it treats its weakest members. Whether the most marginalized people in a culture—the poor, the sick, minorities, the downtrodden—can still maintain basic dignity and aren't treated as disposable, that is the true litmus test.
Chinese civilization uses patriarchal clans and local community bonds to weave the isolated individual into a network of kinship and geography; even if it’s rudimentary, it provides them with a meal and a place to stand. Islamic doctrine, through almsgiving and communal dua, allows the most impoverished to find their place within the collective. Western rights discourse uses institutions to build defenses for the weak; though imperfect, it at least establishes a standard to hold power publicly accountable. African village traditions use sharing and festivals to let those living through famine and war catch their breath within the rhythm of the group.
None of these approaches are pure; all carry the risk of being co-opted by power or swallowed by the market. Yet, in the wind and snow of the Liupan Mountains, under the dim light of a mud house, in the long winds of the grasslands, and among the drumbeats at the intersection of forest and desert, I still choose to believe in a stubborn, cleansing spirit that appears in different civilizations under different names, resisting the cold tendency to treat human beings as mere tools or numbers.
I walk along the long mountain road, the ground beneath my feet frozen hard, the path ahead rising in segments. Behind me is the heavy memory this land has pressed upon me; in front of me is a world surrounded by all sorts of 'mainstream' terminology.
How to understand the world’s mainstream culture is a question that, for many who call themselves intellectuals, easily becomes a word game. They move concepts around in their studies and rank the superiority of civilizations in lecture halls, talking about tolerance and dialogue while their eyes are often clouded with the arrogance of perspective. I don't want to repeat their path.
I would rather respond in a slower way: walking on the loess mountains, standing by the residual snow in Xihaigu, listening to the night wind in a mud house, touching the damp earth in front of a weathered cave dwelling, and then bringing the theories of distant civilizations, small experimental data, and those so-called cutting-edge theories, one by one, to this place—setting them on the earthen kang (heated brick bed) and beside the lonely graves, just to see how much weight they truly hold.
Perhaps in the end, I will only get some blurry answers:
Chinese civilization teaches me that a person must have a sense of shame; even if you're so poor that all you have left is rags, you must hold onto a bottom line that cannot be sold. Islamic civilization reminds me that there are judgments in this world higher than the pursuit of a livelihood, and beliefs more stable than current power; one should not forget the longing for ultimate justice. Western civilization forces me to learn how to doubt myself, to use the light of reason to illuminate blind faith, to restrain power with institutions, and to reflect on prejudices with science. African culture, meanwhile, helps me remember that the movement of the body and the drumbeat of the collective can carry trauma, that memory isn't just found on paper, and dignity isn't maintained by words alone.
These realizations are rough and unsystematic; they wouldn't hold up in an academic debate. But I am willing to stand by them because they were gained through walking, honed bit by bit in the wind and snow, on the loess soil, and before the residual snow on abandoned graves.
I head back from the snowy road of the Liupan Mountains as twilight approaches. The black goats on the ridge are being herded into their pens, the waning moon hangs higher, and a faint, dim yellow light filters through the cracks in the mud cottage windows. The snow on the old graves grows deeper, the shadows of the crumbling cave dwellings grow darker, and the wind circles the earthen slopes.
The world's mainstream culture is debating in far-off places, shouting slogans in conference halls, on the internet, and on paper. I cannot hear those echoes; I only hear the silence emanating from the ground beneath my feet.
Perhaps one day, when these four winds blow harder, and more children hold books from distant lands in their hands, learning the languages of other places through screens, they will understand the big words—Chinese, Islamic, Western, African—in new ways, finding more precise explanations in new laboratories and fields. I am no longer young, and I won't be around for that final conclusion.
All I can do is write down these feelings from the loess today and pass them on to those younger than me.
When that time comes, if they happen to pass through the Liupan Mountains in the deep snow, walk past the mud houses, and weave between the black goats on the ridge and the snow-covered graves, they might suddenly feel a touch of hesitation: when faced with the glittering mainstream of the distant world, how should one place one's own steps? How to be neither kneeling nor drawing a sword? How to be neither inferior nor blindly arrogant?
If they find themselves stuck with this question, then I will know that this long mountain road was not walked in vain. view all
Standing on the rugged loess soil of the Liupan Mountains, I want to explore the deep-seated barriers in communication between the world’s major civilizations from both historical and contemporary perspectives. By dissecting the divisions caused by cultural centrism and cognitive arrogance, we must call for an open-minded approach grounded in humble listening and mutual respect to foster meaningful dialogue among diverse cultures.
The loess mountains look grim in the morning light, with gully after gully stacked up like faded scripture pages that you want to read but can never quite make out. I’m standing on the shadowed slope of the Liupan Mountains. Beneath my feet is a mountain path polished smooth by snow, and in the distance, the leftover snow still glimmers on the ridges of Xihaigu, a bone-chilling white like an old vow buried deep in the earth that refuses to fade away even in this day and age. A wind blows down from the north, carrying sand, bits of dry grass, and half-heard languages, pushing one far away from the familiar edges of home.
I’ve always felt that certain questions have to be asked at passes like this—in the hours when the wind is howling and the snow is just about to lock everything down—only then can the heart be truly honest. For example, how do we understand the "mainstream cultures" that everyone talks about these days: Chinese, Islamic, Western, or the songs and drumbeats of Africa? Talk about this at a desk, and it sounds greasy; say it while walking on the loess soil, and your tongue feels heavy and the words turn hard.
I’m carrying an old, well-worn backpack filled with scholars' books and a few printed papers with English titles, all discussing how civilization, faith, and the human mind are molded by different cultures. The data in labs is cold, and I always feel a bit of hesitation bringing those charts and curves into these parched loess ravines. But since we live in an age where science is the yardstick, I can't just rely on intuition like I used to, so I have to force these cold graphs and the coarse soil together to see if they can still make a real, honest sound.
The long mountain path stretches forward, flanked by mud houses with walls stained dark brown by years of smoke, and ice hanging from the eaves like rows upon rows of frozen question marks. Black goats on the ridges are scattered among the gravel and melting snow, heads bobbing as they tear dry grass from the ground. A sliver of a moon hangs on the horizon, as grey and white as bone, lingering in the narrow space between the sunlight and the wind.
On mornings like this, I like to imagine the four cultures as four winds blowing from different directions, colliding and tangling on this uneven rock we call the world. Anthropologists have long reminded us that culture isn't a flat map; it's a piece of rugged terrain where multiple highlands rise simultaneously, with different civilizations feeling their way up their own slopes, and no one can take another’s steps for them. It’s just that as history unfolded, it was written as a single line. Many writers took the easy way out, starting the clock on the other side of the distant ocean, then using a thick line to turn the scale of civilization into a rigid ruler, leaving the world measured and broken into scattered pieces.
When I read those books in my youth, I felt anxious. The books depicted Chinese civilization as an ancient and enclosed basin, the Islamic world as a mixture of passion and tradition, and Africans as reduced to songs, tribes, and scars. As for the West, there was only a sense of taken-for-granted affirmation—science, reason, the individual, and rights—as if these words could only naturally describe one region, one skin color. Years later, sitting in the mud houses of Xihaigu, on the Gobi Desert of Xinjiang, or beside the ice-thawed riverbeds of the north, I sifted through those claims over and over, slowly learning to re-examine those high-gloss, preconceived terms against the much harsher reality.
I suspect that only by standing on our own solid earth can these four cultures truly reveal themselves, like four travelers arriving from afar, each carrying their own dust and old wounds, sitting together in a mud cabin where the fire is small, the tea is weak, and no one tries to speak too loudly.
The Loess Plateau speaks first.
The culture of this land doesn't rely on noisy proclamations; it presses its truths beneath the soil, burying memories between desolate graves and residual snow. Scholars love to talk about "civilization types" or the "Axial Age," framing Chinese civilization as a massive entity with a skeleton of texts, rituals, and dynasties, as if all that rolled across this continent was just a political history from the Zhou Dynasty to today. Having spent so much time in the villages, I feel more and more that this view is far too dismissive of the grassroots.
The true roots of China are rarely in temples or stone tablets, but in the dark corners of loess cave dwellings, in the breath exhaled on the edge of a *kang* (heated brick bed) in deep winter, and in the feet of farmers silently stepping into the silt after a flood. Modern scholarship is beginning to shift this way, with sociology and anthropology studies moving their focus from the center to the edges, claiming to rewrite a bottom-up history of China and seeking to understand a society of "relational embeddedness"—where people aren't isolated individuals, but are bound by invisible ropes of kinship, local roots, and integrity. The networks woven by these ropes are thicker than legal clauses and more solid than the discourse of rights.
While these theories circle each other on paper, the loess has already lived them out. The mud houses of Xihaigu, the long paths between mountains, the calloused hands of the farmers, the muffled sighs of women at night—these are all nodes in this network. It defines what it means to be "home," what "human sentiment" is, what "face" is, and what "shame" is. It also answers the question "Who am I?" very specifically—I am the son of this family in this village, a person in this gully, a handful of soil by the ancestral graves.
With Chinese culture so deeply rooted, it naturally has an instinctive reaction to the winds from outside. It is not showy, not easily excited, and its wariness is laced with curiosity, while its curiosity carries a simple self-confidence. For over a century, the winds of the West, Islam, and Africa have all swept across this land. City dwellers quickly learned to use words like "globalization," but the Loess Plateau is more cautious; it first tests the temperature of these winds with its own thick soil. What it can handle, it absorbs and turns into a new layer of itself; winds that blow too fast are made to circle the mountain passes twice and slow down.
On the other side of the Liupan Mountains, I encountered the wind of Islam.
It was a day of heavy snow that sealed the mountains, leaving the ridges of Xihaigu a uniform grey and white. In a mud house in a village, I heard an elder softly reciting scriptures—not in the uniform tone heard in city mosques, but with a local accent, family whispers, long-suppressed frustrations, and a humble sense of pride. The word "Islam" is too vast on a world map; when scholars write about it, they often get stuck in the shadows of politics and violence, rarely lowering their heads to see how ordinary believers maintain their discipline in a desolate life.
The Islam I saw in the loess cave dwellings wasn't some abstract buzzword, but a low-key, disciplined way of life. Washing hands and faces, raising hands for *dua* (supplication/prayer), observing dietary restrictions, holding one's tongue, and when suffering bears down, leaving behind a word of "submission." But that submission isn't surrender to power; it’s a form of finding peace within oneself amidst misery. I later read research in religion and cognitive science suggesting that long-term prayer and collective *masjid* (mosque) worship strengthen brain regions related to communal feeling and order, making it easier for people to experience the existence of a "community" and enhancing unity and endurance in hardship. These differences, visible in cold charts, were long ago etched into these barren mountain villages.
Islamic culture is like a river winding from deserts, oases, and grasslands. It passed through the ethnic groups of our Northwest, leaving behind clean diets, solemn rituals, and generous hospitality, along with a stubbornness that refuses to retreat easily. I walked through empty valleys and heard young shepherds talk of distant holy lands, their eyes gleaming in the moonlight; inside them was a faith in ultimate justice, an expectation of divine judgment, and a longing for the grievances of this life to be washed away in the next world.
Compared to a culture that finds its return in "The One," Chinese civilization is more like a thick clay accustomed to compromise and harmony, allowing for multiple gods and ancestors to coexist. It permits Confucianism, Buddhism, and Taoism to layer upon each other, allowing ancestral tablets to sit alongside abstract concepts. So when the two meet, tensions inevitably arise at certain points: one emphasizes absolute truth, the other is used to diversity; one emphasizes commandments, the other trusts more in human sentiment. But what I saw on the Northwest Loess Plateau was another scene entirely—the two cultures avoiding direct collision, choosing instead to live quietly side-by-side in daily life.
I still remember those times in the residual snow of Xihaigu when people gathered for the collective visiting of graves. The loess ridge was all white, and people gathered from every direction; white headscarves fluttered in the wind, and the repressed historical memories in their chests were awakened by unified movements and sounds. It was a belief forged through tragic events and the cost of blood, a spiritual history rarely written about head-on in mainstream textbooks. Every major religion in the world has been embroiled in power and violence in some way, but in the daily lives of these grassroots believers, faith acts more like a rope that pulls people out of failure and poverty, allowing them to keep a shred of dignity in extreme hardship.
Crossing the Tianshan Mountains, I heard ballads on the grasslands that blended Islamic and nomadic traditions. Under the vast sky, the stars were cold; human voices blended with drumbeats, and saddles and sandalwood paperweights bore witness to time sinking suffering into the internal textures of the soul. The modern World-Systems theory loves to talk about "center-periphery," placing the Islamic world and many parts of Africa and Latin America at the exploited end, discussing economics, resources, and trade structures. Structurally, these points have merit, but I always feel they can't fully capture the soul of a people.
In that vastness, I felt another confrontation: facing the single-path narrative represented by the West, those civilizations classified as "the periphery" are silently maintaining a different cosmic order with their own scriptures, drumbeats, and desolate graves on the loess soil.
The wind of Western culture has been blowing across the seas and into our continent for a long time.
Books tell me its core is reason, science, the individual, and rights—a whole set of cognitive methods supported by empiricism, laboratories, and mathematical models. As anthropologists lament the disintegration of traditional societies, young people in many places have already learned to use this logic to explain the world: the world can be precisely measured, history can be pushed linearly, and the individual is a self-sufficient unit that can separate from family and the earth, connecting with others solely through contracts and law.
I don't deny the value of these achievements. Modern natural science has liberated many from disease and hunger, peeled back the structure of the universe bit by bit, and stripped away layers of human cognitive bias. Interdisciplinary research in cognitive psychology, cultural neuroscience, and anthropology allows us to see that people in different cultures truly leave traces in their brains regarding their understanding of self, groups, and fairness. These findings help us recognize differences more calmly and stop easily judging entire civilizations as "superior" or "inferior."
The problem arises when this way of explaining the world is absolutized by some, treated as the only yardstick, and the richness of other civilizations is compressed into being "pre-modern" or "backward." World-systems theorists, post-colonial scholars, and researchers of civilizational diversity have spent decades deconstructing this single-line theory. They tell us that Western modernity is also a specific historical path, the result of a specific geography, religion, and economic structure, rather than a universal template that everyone must follow.
Standing on the banks of a river in the North as the ice began to break, I spent a long time thinking about this. As the ice on the river started to shift, water came roaring up from underneath, pushing the jagged chunks aside, and when the sunlight hit it, the surface glistened. In that moment, I knew clearly: if any one culture on this planet claims the title of 'modern' exclusively, leaving no room for other civilizations to speak, that is a dangerous kind of poverty.
Western culture offers a powerful toolkit—scientific methods, institutional design, human rights discourse, and democratic ideals. These are things countries across the globe can selectively borrow to improve their lives, build fairer societies, and protect human dignity. But it cannot, and should not, erase the depth of the Chinese loess plateau, the devotion found in Islamic scriptures, or the rhythm of life in African drumbeats.
When I think of African culture, I’m reminded of a young man I met in the borderlands who had just returned from his studies in Africa. At a snowy outpost, he told me about grasslands beyond the ones I knew—where the grass is greener, the sky is bluer, and cattle and drumbeats interweave by evening campfires. He talked about village elders, market chants, the patterns painted on skin during rituals, and how they navigate between the memory of colonialism and the hope for the future. Anthropologists have long listened to those voices in the forests and the Sahel region of Africa, documenting oral histories, myths, and kinship systems, while reflecting on the arrogance that once used evolutionary theories to hold others down.
For a long time, the true depth of African civilization was misunderstood by the world. Some media outlets only like to focus on war, disease, and poverty as the main themes, occasionally tossing in a shallow nod to 'primitive joy.' This kind of narrative is neither fair nor serious. Later scholarship has begun to correct this, highlighting the complexity of Africa's diverse ethnic groups, languages, and religions, emphasizing the wisdom in oral traditions, and focusing on ethics centered on the collective and a deep sensitivity to natural rhythms.
Behind those words, I always picture another scene I’ve seen on the grasslands of the Northwest: the withering and flourishing of wild grass, the movement of groups, the blending of drumbeats and horse hooves, where people feel as much like dust as they do sparks of fire. The dancing of African people under the scorching sun and the rhythm of their drums aren't so different in spirit from the long, flowing folk songs of our Northern grasslands, the drumbeats of Central Asia, or the dua (supplication/prayer) of the Arab world. They are all humanity’s shared response to the earth, to life, and to death—using the body to remember and rhythm to face an unknowable fate.
Thinking about this amid the heavy snowfall in the Liupan Mountains, a rough map of the human spirit began to unfold in my mind.
Chinese civilization is like a great loess mountain—topped with residual snow, rooted in ancient graves; the legal and ritual codes are like layers of stacked earth, with scriptures buried alongside farming tools. Islamic civilization is like a river flowing from a sea of sand, lingering near the snow line, carrying a strict rhythm that washes away human desires again and again, teaching people to find freedom within discipline. Western civilization is like a machine that is constantly self-deconstructing and reassembling, skilled at looking at itself with skepticism, upgrading its tools, and measuring the world with precision. African culture is like a grassland panting in the heat: the surface is all dance and song, but underneath lies a profound, lingering trauma and resilience, rising again and again after being beaten down, using the rhythm of the body to mend the cracks left by history.
These labels have their limitations, but I’m no longer interested in swapping them for fancier terms. Academia already has too many complex concepts: dialogue of civilizations, multiple modernities, post-colonial context, cultural psychological structures... these words have their place, and I’ve been inspired by them too. But standing at the doorway of a mud house in Xihaigu, watching black goats forage for grass on the edge of the snow above an old cave dwelling, I trust the simplest judgment more—every civilization has tempered its bones in extreme environments and has its own way of upholding human dignity.
The problem isn't the differences themselves; the problem is the arrogance.
The pattern of the world’s mainstream culture isn't a fixed table; it’s a flowing river. The Chinese, Islamic, Western, and African traditions have all been pushed to the center or the margins at different points in history. In our era, technology and capital make information move fast, making some discourses easy to amplify and other voices easy to drown out. The media loves chasing the 'mainstream' label, as if whatever is mentioned most often is the core, while the quiet, the patient, and the remote can be ignored.
Having stood before the abandoned graves in Xihaigu for a long time, another bottom line formed in my heart: what defines a civilization shouldn't be its volume, but how it treats its weakest members. Whether the most marginalized people in a culture—the poor, the sick, minorities, the downtrodden—can still maintain basic dignity and aren't treated as disposable, that is the true litmus test.
Chinese civilization uses patriarchal clans and local community bonds to weave the isolated individual into a network of kinship and geography; even if it’s rudimentary, it provides them with a meal and a place to stand. Islamic doctrine, through almsgiving and communal dua, allows the most impoverished to find their place within the collective. Western rights discourse uses institutions to build defenses for the weak; though imperfect, it at least establishes a standard to hold power publicly accountable. African village traditions use sharing and festivals to let those living through famine and war catch their breath within the rhythm of the group.
None of these approaches are pure; all carry the risk of being co-opted by power or swallowed by the market. Yet, in the wind and snow of the Liupan Mountains, under the dim light of a mud house, in the long winds of the grasslands, and among the drumbeats at the intersection of forest and desert, I still choose to believe in a stubborn, cleansing spirit that appears in different civilizations under different names, resisting the cold tendency to treat human beings as mere tools or numbers.
I walk along the long mountain road, the ground beneath my feet frozen hard, the path ahead rising in segments. Behind me is the heavy memory this land has pressed upon me; in front of me is a world surrounded by all sorts of 'mainstream' terminology.
How to understand the world’s mainstream culture is a question that, for many who call themselves intellectuals, easily becomes a word game. They move concepts around in their studies and rank the superiority of civilizations in lecture halls, talking about tolerance and dialogue while their eyes are often clouded with the arrogance of perspective. I don't want to repeat their path.
I would rather respond in a slower way: walking on the loess mountains, standing by the residual snow in Xihaigu, listening to the night wind in a mud house, touching the damp earth in front of a weathered cave dwelling, and then bringing the theories of distant civilizations, small experimental data, and those so-called cutting-edge theories, one by one, to this place—setting them on the earthen kang (heated brick bed) and beside the lonely graves, just to see how much weight they truly hold.
Perhaps in the end, I will only get some blurry answers:
Chinese civilization teaches me that a person must have a sense of shame; even if you're so poor that all you have left is rags, you must hold onto a bottom line that cannot be sold. Islamic civilization reminds me that there are judgments in this world higher than the pursuit of a livelihood, and beliefs more stable than current power; one should not forget the longing for ultimate justice. Western civilization forces me to learn how to doubt myself, to use the light of reason to illuminate blind faith, to restrain power with institutions, and to reflect on prejudices with science. African culture, meanwhile, helps me remember that the movement of the body and the drumbeat of the collective can carry trauma, that memory isn't just found on paper, and dignity isn't maintained by words alone.
These realizations are rough and unsystematic; they wouldn't hold up in an academic debate. But I am willing to stand by them because they were gained through walking, honed bit by bit in the wind and snow, on the loess soil, and before the residual snow on abandoned graves.
I head back from the snowy road of the Liupan Mountains as twilight approaches. The black goats on the ridge are being herded into their pens, the waning moon hangs higher, and a faint, dim yellow light filters through the cracks in the mud cottage windows. The snow on the old graves grows deeper, the shadows of the crumbling cave dwellings grow darker, and the wind circles the earthen slopes.
The world's mainstream culture is debating in far-off places, shouting slogans in conference halls, on the internet, and on paper. I cannot hear those echoes; I only hear the silence emanating from the ground beneath my feet.
Perhaps one day, when these four winds blow harder, and more children hold books from distant lands in their hands, learning the languages of other places through screens, they will understand the big words—Chinese, Islamic, Western, African—in new ways, finding more precise explanations in new laboratories and fields. I am no longer young, and I won't be around for that final conclusion.
All I can do is write down these feelings from the loess today and pass them on to those younger than me.
When that time comes, if they happen to pass through the Liupan Mountains in the deep snow, walk past the mud houses, and weave between the black goats on the ridge and the snow-covered graves, they might suddenly feel a touch of hesitation: when faced with the glittering mainstream of the distant world, how should one place one's own steps? How to be neither kneeling nor drawing a sword? How to be neither inferior nor blindly arrogant?
If they find themselves stuck with this question, then I will know that this long mountain road was not walked in vain. view all
[Internet Repost]
Standing on the rugged loess soil of the Liupan Mountains, I want to explore the deep-seated barriers in communication between the world’s major civilizations from both historical and contemporary perspectives. By dissecting the divisions caused by cultural centrism and cognitive arrogance, we must call for an open-minded approach grounded in humble listening and mutual respect to foster meaningful dialogue among diverse cultures.
The loess mountains look grim in the morning light, with gully after gully stacked up like faded scripture pages that you want to read but can never quite make out. I’m standing on the shadowed slope of the Liupan Mountains. Beneath my feet is a mountain path polished smooth by snow, and in the distance, the leftover snow still glimmers on the ridges of Xihaigu, a bone-chilling white like an old vow buried deep in the earth that refuses to fade away even in this day and age. A wind blows down from the north, carrying sand, bits of dry grass, and half-heard languages, pushing one far away from the familiar edges of home.
I’ve always felt that certain questions have to be asked at passes like this—in the hours when the wind is howling and the snow is just about to lock everything down—only then can the heart be truly honest. For example, how do we understand the "mainstream cultures" that everyone talks about these days: Chinese, Islamic, Western, or the songs and drumbeats of Africa? Talk about this at a desk, and it sounds greasy; say it while walking on the loess soil, and your tongue feels heavy and the words turn hard.
I’m carrying an old, well-worn backpack filled with scholars' books and a few printed papers with English titles, all discussing how civilization, faith, and the human mind are molded by different cultures. The data in labs is cold, and I always feel a bit of hesitation bringing those charts and curves into these parched loess ravines. But since we live in an age where science is the yardstick, I can't just rely on intuition like I used to, so I have to force these cold graphs and the coarse soil together to see if they can still make a real, honest sound.
The long mountain path stretches forward, flanked by mud houses with walls stained dark brown by years of smoke, and ice hanging from the eaves like rows upon rows of frozen question marks. Black goats on the ridges are scattered among the gravel and melting snow, heads bobbing as they tear dry grass from the ground. A sliver of a moon hangs on the horizon, as grey and white as bone, lingering in the narrow space between the sunlight and the wind.
On mornings like this, I like to imagine the four cultures as four winds blowing from different directions, colliding and tangling on this uneven rock we call the world. Anthropologists have long reminded us that culture isn't a flat map; it's a piece of rugged terrain where multiple highlands rise simultaneously, with different civilizations feeling their way up their own slopes, and no one can take another’s steps for them. It’s just that as history unfolded, it was written as a single line. Many writers took the easy way out, starting the clock on the other side of the distant ocean, then using a thick line to turn the scale of civilization into a rigid ruler, leaving the world measured and broken into scattered pieces.
When I read those books in my youth, I felt anxious. The books depicted Chinese civilization as an ancient and enclosed basin, the Islamic world as a mixture of passion and tradition, and Africans as reduced to songs, tribes, and scars. As for the West, there was only a sense of taken-for-granted affirmation—science, reason, the individual, and rights—as if these words could only naturally describe one region, one skin color. Years later, sitting in the mud houses of Xihaigu, on the Gobi Desert of Xinjiang, or beside the ice-thawed riverbeds of the north, I sifted through those claims over and over, slowly learning to re-examine those high-gloss, preconceived terms against the much harsher reality.
I suspect that only by standing on our own solid earth can these four cultures truly reveal themselves, like four travelers arriving from afar, each carrying their own dust and old wounds, sitting together in a mud cabin where the fire is small, the tea is weak, and no one tries to speak too loudly.
The Loess Plateau speaks first.
The culture of this land doesn't rely on noisy proclamations; it presses its truths beneath the soil, burying memories between desolate graves and residual snow. Scholars love to talk about "civilization types" or the "Axial Age," framing Chinese civilization as a massive entity with a skeleton of texts, rituals, and dynasties, as if all that rolled across this continent was just a political history from the Zhou Dynasty to today. Having spent so much time in the villages, I feel more and more that this view is far too dismissive of the grassroots.
The true roots of China are rarely in temples or stone tablets, but in the dark corners of loess cave dwellings, in the breath exhaled on the edge of a *kang* (heated brick bed) in deep winter, and in the feet of farmers silently stepping into the silt after a flood. Modern scholarship is beginning to shift this way, with sociology and anthropology studies moving their focus from the center to the edges, claiming to rewrite a bottom-up history of China and seeking to understand a society of "relational embeddedness"—where people aren't isolated individuals, but are bound by invisible ropes of kinship, local roots, and integrity. The networks woven by these ropes are thicker than legal clauses and more solid than the discourse of rights.
While these theories circle each other on paper, the loess has already lived them out. The mud houses of Xihaigu, the long paths between mountains, the calloused hands of the farmers, the muffled sighs of women at night—these are all nodes in this network. It defines what it means to be "home," what "human sentiment" is, what "face" is, and what "shame" is. It also answers the question "Who am I?" very specifically—I am the son of this family in this village, a person in this gully, a handful of soil by the ancestral graves.
With Chinese culture so deeply rooted, it naturally has an instinctive reaction to the winds from outside. It is not showy, not easily excited, and its wariness is laced with curiosity, while its curiosity carries a simple self-confidence. For over a century, the winds of the West, Islam, and Africa have all swept across this land. City dwellers quickly learned to use words like "globalization," but the Loess Plateau is more cautious; it first tests the temperature of these winds with its own thick soil. What it can handle, it absorbs and turns into a new layer of itself; winds that blow too fast are made to circle the mountain passes twice and slow down.
On the other side of the Liupan Mountains, I encountered the wind of Islam.
It was a day of heavy snow that sealed the mountains, leaving the ridges of Xihaigu a uniform grey and white. In a mud house in a village, I heard an elder softly reciting scriptures—not in the uniform tone heard in city mosques, but with a local accent, family whispers, long-suppressed frustrations, and a humble sense of pride. The word "Islam" is too vast on a world map; when scholars write about it, they often get stuck in the shadows of politics and violence, rarely lowering their heads to see how ordinary believers maintain their discipline in a desolate life.
The Islam I saw in the loess cave dwellings wasn't some abstract buzzword, but a low-key, disciplined way of life. Washing hands and faces, raising hands for *dua* (supplication/prayer), observing dietary restrictions, holding one's tongue, and when suffering bears down, leaving behind a word of "submission." But that submission isn't surrender to power; it’s a form of finding peace within oneself amidst misery. I later read research in religion and cognitive science suggesting that long-term prayer and collective *masjid* (mosque) worship strengthen brain regions related to communal feeling and order, making it easier for people to experience the existence of a "community" and enhancing unity and endurance in hardship. These differences, visible in cold charts, were long ago etched into these barren mountain villages.
Islamic culture is like a river winding from deserts, oases, and grasslands. It passed through the ethnic groups of our Northwest, leaving behind clean diets, solemn rituals, and generous hospitality, along with a stubbornness that refuses to retreat easily. I walked through empty valleys and heard young shepherds talk of distant holy lands, their eyes gleaming in the moonlight; inside them was a faith in ultimate justice, an expectation of divine judgment, and a longing for the grievances of this life to be washed away in the next world.
Compared to a culture that finds its return in "The One," Chinese civilization is more like a thick clay accustomed to compromise and harmony, allowing for multiple gods and ancestors to coexist. It permits Confucianism, Buddhism, and Taoism to layer upon each other, allowing ancestral tablets to sit alongside abstract concepts. So when the two meet, tensions inevitably arise at certain points: one emphasizes absolute truth, the other is used to diversity; one emphasizes commandments, the other trusts more in human sentiment. But what I saw on the Northwest Loess Plateau was another scene entirely—the two cultures avoiding direct collision, choosing instead to live quietly side-by-side in daily life.
I still remember those times in the residual snow of Xihaigu when people gathered for the collective visiting of graves. The loess ridge was all white, and people gathered from every direction; white headscarves fluttered in the wind, and the repressed historical memories in their chests were awakened by unified movements and sounds. It was a belief forged through tragic events and the cost of blood, a spiritual history rarely written about head-on in mainstream textbooks. Every major religion in the world has been embroiled in power and violence in some way, but in the daily lives of these grassroots believers, faith acts more like a rope that pulls people out of failure and poverty, allowing them to keep a shred of dignity in extreme hardship.
Crossing the Tianshan Mountains, I heard ballads on the grasslands that blended Islamic and nomadic traditions. Under the vast sky, the stars were cold; human voices blended with drumbeats, and saddles and sandalwood paperweights bore witness to time sinking suffering into the internal textures of the soul. The modern World-Systems theory loves to talk about "center-periphery," placing the Islamic world and many parts of Africa and Latin America at the exploited end, discussing economics, resources, and trade structures. Structurally, these points have merit, but I always feel they can't fully capture the soul of a people.
In that vastness, I felt another confrontation: facing the single-path narrative represented by the West, those civilizations classified as "the periphery" are silently maintaining a different cosmic order with their own scriptures, drumbeats, and desolate graves on the loess soil.
The wind of Western culture has been blowing across the seas and into our continent for a long time.
Books tell me its core is reason, science, the individual, and rights—a whole set of cognitive methods supported by empiricism, laboratories, and mathematical models. As anthropologists lament the disintegration of traditional societies, young people in many places have already learned to use this logic to explain the world: the world can be precisely measured, history can be pushed linearly, and the individual is a self-sufficient unit that can separate from family and the earth, connecting with others solely through contracts and law.
I don't deny the value of these achievements. Modern natural science has liberated many from disease and hunger, peeled back the structure of the universe bit by bit, and stripped away layers of human cognitive bias. Interdisciplinary research in cognitive psychology, cultural neuroscience, and anthropology allows us to see that people in different cultures truly leave traces in their brains regarding their understanding of self, groups, and fairness. These findings help us recognize differences more calmly and stop easily judging entire civilizations as "superior" or "inferior."
The problem arises when this way of explaining the world is absolutized by some, treated as the only yardstick, and the richness of other civilizations is compressed into being "pre-modern" or "backward." World-systems theorists, post-colonial scholars, and researchers of civilizational diversity have spent decades deconstructing this single-line theory. They tell us that Western modernity is also a specific historical path, the result of a specific geography, religion, and economic structure, rather than a universal template that everyone must follow.
Standing on the banks of a river in the North as the ice began to break, I spent a long time thinking about this. As the ice on the river started to shift, water came roaring up from underneath, pushing the jagged chunks aside, and when the sunlight hit it, the surface glistened. In that moment, I knew clearly: if any one culture on this planet claims the title of 'modern' exclusively, leaving no room for other civilizations to speak, that is a dangerous kind of poverty.
Western culture offers a powerful toolkit—scientific methods, institutional design, human rights discourse, and democratic ideals. These are things countries across the globe can selectively borrow to improve their lives, build fairer societies, and protect human dignity. But it cannot, and should not, erase the depth of the Chinese loess plateau, the devotion found in Islamic scriptures, or the rhythm of life in African drumbeats.
When I think of African culture, I’m reminded of a young man I met in the borderlands who had just returned from his studies in Africa. At a snowy outpost, he told me about grasslands beyond the ones I knew—where the grass is greener, the sky is bluer, and cattle and drumbeats interweave by evening campfires. He talked about village elders, market chants, the patterns painted on skin during rituals, and how they navigate between the memory of colonialism and the hope for the future. Anthropologists have long listened to those voices in the forests and the Sahel region of Africa, documenting oral histories, myths, and kinship systems, while reflecting on the arrogance that once used evolutionary theories to hold others down.
For a long time, the true depth of African civilization was misunderstood by the world. Some media outlets only like to focus on war, disease, and poverty as the main themes, occasionally tossing in a shallow nod to 'primitive joy.' This kind of narrative is neither fair nor serious. Later scholarship has begun to correct this, highlighting the complexity of Africa's diverse ethnic groups, languages, and religions, emphasizing the wisdom in oral traditions, and focusing on ethics centered on the collective and a deep sensitivity to natural rhythms.
Behind those words, I always picture another scene I’ve seen on the grasslands of the Northwest: the withering and flourishing of wild grass, the movement of groups, the blending of drumbeats and horse hooves, where people feel as much like dust as they do sparks of fire. The dancing of African people under the scorching sun and the rhythm of their drums aren't so different in spirit from the long, flowing folk songs of our Northern grasslands, the drumbeats of Central Asia, or the dua (supplication/prayer) of the Arab world. They are all humanity’s shared response to the earth, to life, and to death—using the body to remember and rhythm to face an unknowable fate.
Thinking about this amid the heavy snowfall in the Liupan Mountains, a rough map of the human spirit began to unfold in my mind.
Chinese civilization is like a great loess mountain—topped with residual snow, rooted in ancient graves; the legal and ritual codes are like layers of stacked earth, with scriptures buried alongside farming tools. Islamic civilization is like a river flowing from a sea of sand, lingering near the snow line, carrying a strict rhythm that washes away human desires again and again, teaching people to find freedom within discipline. Western civilization is like a machine that is constantly self-deconstructing and reassembling, skilled at looking at itself with skepticism, upgrading its tools, and measuring the world with precision. African culture is like a grassland panting in the heat: the surface is all dance and song, but underneath lies a profound, lingering trauma and resilience, rising again and again after being beaten down, using the rhythm of the body to mend the cracks left by history.
These labels have their limitations, but I’m no longer interested in swapping them for fancier terms. Academia already has too many complex concepts: dialogue of civilizations, multiple modernities, post-colonial context, cultural psychological structures... these words have their place, and I’ve been inspired by them too. But standing at the doorway of a mud house in Xihaigu, watching black goats forage for grass on the edge of the snow above an old cave dwelling, I trust the simplest judgment more—every civilization has tempered its bones in extreme environments and has its own way of upholding human dignity.
The problem isn't the differences themselves; the problem is the arrogance.
The pattern of the world’s mainstream culture isn't a fixed table; it’s a flowing river. The Chinese, Islamic, Western, and African traditions have all been pushed to the center or the margins at different points in history. In our era, technology and capital make information move fast, making some discourses easy to amplify and other voices easy to drown out. The media loves chasing the 'mainstream' label, as if whatever is mentioned most often is the core, while the quiet, the patient, and the remote can be ignored.
Having stood before the abandoned graves in Xihaigu for a long time, another bottom line formed in my heart: what defines a civilization shouldn't be its volume, but how it treats its weakest members. Whether the most marginalized people in a culture—the poor, the sick, minorities, the downtrodden—can still maintain basic dignity and aren't treated as disposable, that is the true litmus test.
Chinese civilization uses patriarchal clans and local community bonds to weave the isolated individual into a network of kinship and geography; even if it’s rudimentary, it provides them with a meal and a place to stand. Islamic doctrine, through almsgiving and communal dua, allows the most impoverished to find their place within the collective. Western rights discourse uses institutions to build defenses for the weak; though imperfect, it at least establishes a standard to hold power publicly accountable. African village traditions use sharing and festivals to let those living through famine and war catch their breath within the rhythm of the group.
None of these approaches are pure; all carry the risk of being co-opted by power or swallowed by the market. Yet, in the wind and snow of the Liupan Mountains, under the dim light of a mud house, in the long winds of the grasslands, and among the drumbeats at the intersection of forest and desert, I still choose to believe in a stubborn, cleansing spirit that appears in different civilizations under different names, resisting the cold tendency to treat human beings as mere tools or numbers.
I walk along the long mountain road, the ground beneath my feet frozen hard, the path ahead rising in segments. Behind me is the heavy memory this land has pressed upon me; in front of me is a world surrounded by all sorts of 'mainstream' terminology.
How to understand the world’s mainstream culture is a question that, for many who call themselves intellectuals, easily becomes a word game. They move concepts around in their studies and rank the superiority of civilizations in lecture halls, talking about tolerance and dialogue while their eyes are often clouded with the arrogance of perspective. I don't want to repeat their path.
I would rather respond in a slower way: walking on the loess mountains, standing by the residual snow in Xihaigu, listening to the night wind in a mud house, touching the damp earth in front of a weathered cave dwelling, and then bringing the theories of distant civilizations, small experimental data, and those so-called cutting-edge theories, one by one, to this place—setting them on the earthen kang (heated brick bed) and beside the lonely graves, just to see how much weight they truly hold.
Perhaps in the end, I will only get some blurry answers:
Chinese civilization teaches me that a person must have a sense of shame; even if you're so poor that all you have left is rags, you must hold onto a bottom line that cannot be sold. Islamic civilization reminds me that there are judgments in this world higher than the pursuit of a livelihood, and beliefs more stable than current power; one should not forget the longing for ultimate justice. Western civilization forces me to learn how to doubt myself, to use the light of reason to illuminate blind faith, to restrain power with institutions, and to reflect on prejudices with science. African culture, meanwhile, helps me remember that the movement of the body and the drumbeat of the collective can carry trauma, that memory isn't just found on paper, and dignity isn't maintained by words alone.
These realizations are rough and unsystematic; they wouldn't hold up in an academic debate. But I am willing to stand by them because they were gained through walking, honed bit by bit in the wind and snow, on the loess soil, and before the residual snow on abandoned graves.
I head back from the snowy road of the Liupan Mountains as twilight approaches. The black goats on the ridge are being herded into their pens, the waning moon hangs higher, and a faint, dim yellow light filters through the cracks in the mud cottage windows. The snow on the old graves grows deeper, the shadows of the crumbling cave dwellings grow darker, and the wind circles the earthen slopes.
The world's mainstream culture is debating in far-off places, shouting slogans in conference halls, on the internet, and on paper. I cannot hear those echoes; I only hear the silence emanating from the ground beneath my feet.
Perhaps one day, when these four winds blow harder, and more children hold books from distant lands in their hands, learning the languages of other places through screens, they will understand the big words—Chinese, Islamic, Western, African—in new ways, finding more precise explanations in new laboratories and fields. I am no longer young, and I won't be around for that final conclusion.
All I can do is write down these feelings from the loess today and pass them on to those younger than me.
When that time comes, if they happen to pass through the Liupan Mountains in the deep snow, walk past the mud houses, and weave between the black goats on the ridge and the snow-covered graves, they might suddenly feel a touch of hesitation: when faced with the glittering mainstream of the distant world, how should one place one's own steps? How to be neither kneeling nor drawing a sword? How to be neither inferior nor blindly arrogant?
If they find themselves stuck with this question, then I will know that this long mountain road was not walked in vain.
Standing on the rugged loess soil of the Liupan Mountains, I want to explore the deep-seated barriers in communication between the world’s major civilizations from both historical and contemporary perspectives. By dissecting the divisions caused by cultural centrism and cognitive arrogance, we must call for an open-minded approach grounded in humble listening and mutual respect to foster meaningful dialogue among diverse cultures.
The loess mountains look grim in the morning light, with gully after gully stacked up like faded scripture pages that you want to read but can never quite make out. I’m standing on the shadowed slope of the Liupan Mountains. Beneath my feet is a mountain path polished smooth by snow, and in the distance, the leftover snow still glimmers on the ridges of Xihaigu, a bone-chilling white like an old vow buried deep in the earth that refuses to fade away even in this day and age. A wind blows down from the north, carrying sand, bits of dry grass, and half-heard languages, pushing one far away from the familiar edges of home.
I’ve always felt that certain questions have to be asked at passes like this—in the hours when the wind is howling and the snow is just about to lock everything down—only then can the heart be truly honest. For example, how do we understand the "mainstream cultures" that everyone talks about these days: Chinese, Islamic, Western, or the songs and drumbeats of Africa? Talk about this at a desk, and it sounds greasy; say it while walking on the loess soil, and your tongue feels heavy and the words turn hard.
I’m carrying an old, well-worn backpack filled with scholars' books and a few printed papers with English titles, all discussing how civilization, faith, and the human mind are molded by different cultures. The data in labs is cold, and I always feel a bit of hesitation bringing those charts and curves into these parched loess ravines. But since we live in an age where science is the yardstick, I can't just rely on intuition like I used to, so I have to force these cold graphs and the coarse soil together to see if they can still make a real, honest sound.
The long mountain path stretches forward, flanked by mud houses with walls stained dark brown by years of smoke, and ice hanging from the eaves like rows upon rows of frozen question marks. Black goats on the ridges are scattered among the gravel and melting snow, heads bobbing as they tear dry grass from the ground. A sliver of a moon hangs on the horizon, as grey and white as bone, lingering in the narrow space between the sunlight and the wind.
On mornings like this, I like to imagine the four cultures as four winds blowing from different directions, colliding and tangling on this uneven rock we call the world. Anthropologists have long reminded us that culture isn't a flat map; it's a piece of rugged terrain where multiple highlands rise simultaneously, with different civilizations feeling their way up their own slopes, and no one can take another’s steps for them. It’s just that as history unfolded, it was written as a single line. Many writers took the easy way out, starting the clock on the other side of the distant ocean, then using a thick line to turn the scale of civilization into a rigid ruler, leaving the world measured and broken into scattered pieces.
When I read those books in my youth, I felt anxious. The books depicted Chinese civilization as an ancient and enclosed basin, the Islamic world as a mixture of passion and tradition, and Africans as reduced to songs, tribes, and scars. As for the West, there was only a sense of taken-for-granted affirmation—science, reason, the individual, and rights—as if these words could only naturally describe one region, one skin color. Years later, sitting in the mud houses of Xihaigu, on the Gobi Desert of Xinjiang, or beside the ice-thawed riverbeds of the north, I sifted through those claims over and over, slowly learning to re-examine those high-gloss, preconceived terms against the much harsher reality.
I suspect that only by standing on our own solid earth can these four cultures truly reveal themselves, like four travelers arriving from afar, each carrying their own dust and old wounds, sitting together in a mud cabin where the fire is small, the tea is weak, and no one tries to speak too loudly.
The Loess Plateau speaks first.
The culture of this land doesn't rely on noisy proclamations; it presses its truths beneath the soil, burying memories between desolate graves and residual snow. Scholars love to talk about "civilization types" or the "Axial Age," framing Chinese civilization as a massive entity with a skeleton of texts, rituals, and dynasties, as if all that rolled across this continent was just a political history from the Zhou Dynasty to today. Having spent so much time in the villages, I feel more and more that this view is far too dismissive of the grassroots.
The true roots of China are rarely in temples or stone tablets, but in the dark corners of loess cave dwellings, in the breath exhaled on the edge of a *kang* (heated brick bed) in deep winter, and in the feet of farmers silently stepping into the silt after a flood. Modern scholarship is beginning to shift this way, with sociology and anthropology studies moving their focus from the center to the edges, claiming to rewrite a bottom-up history of China and seeking to understand a society of "relational embeddedness"—where people aren't isolated individuals, but are bound by invisible ropes of kinship, local roots, and integrity. The networks woven by these ropes are thicker than legal clauses and more solid than the discourse of rights.
While these theories circle each other on paper, the loess has already lived them out. The mud houses of Xihaigu, the long paths between mountains, the calloused hands of the farmers, the muffled sighs of women at night—these are all nodes in this network. It defines what it means to be "home," what "human sentiment" is, what "face" is, and what "shame" is. It also answers the question "Who am I?" very specifically—I am the son of this family in this village, a person in this gully, a handful of soil by the ancestral graves.
With Chinese culture so deeply rooted, it naturally has an instinctive reaction to the winds from outside. It is not showy, not easily excited, and its wariness is laced with curiosity, while its curiosity carries a simple self-confidence. For over a century, the winds of the West, Islam, and Africa have all swept across this land. City dwellers quickly learned to use words like "globalization," but the Loess Plateau is more cautious; it first tests the temperature of these winds with its own thick soil. What it can handle, it absorbs and turns into a new layer of itself; winds that blow too fast are made to circle the mountain passes twice and slow down.
On the other side of the Liupan Mountains, I encountered the wind of Islam.
It was a day of heavy snow that sealed the mountains, leaving the ridges of Xihaigu a uniform grey and white. In a mud house in a village, I heard an elder softly reciting scriptures—not in the uniform tone heard in city mosques, but with a local accent, family whispers, long-suppressed frustrations, and a humble sense of pride. The word "Islam" is too vast on a world map; when scholars write about it, they often get stuck in the shadows of politics and violence, rarely lowering their heads to see how ordinary believers maintain their discipline in a desolate life.
The Islam I saw in the loess cave dwellings wasn't some abstract buzzword, but a low-key, disciplined way of life. Washing hands and faces, raising hands for *dua* (supplication/prayer), observing dietary restrictions, holding one's tongue, and when suffering bears down, leaving behind a word of "submission." But that submission isn't surrender to power; it’s a form of finding peace within oneself amidst misery. I later read research in religion and cognitive science suggesting that long-term prayer and collective *masjid* (mosque) worship strengthen brain regions related to communal feeling and order, making it easier for people to experience the existence of a "community" and enhancing unity and endurance in hardship. These differences, visible in cold charts, were long ago etched into these barren mountain villages.
Islamic culture is like a river winding from deserts, oases, and grasslands. It passed through the ethnic groups of our Northwest, leaving behind clean diets, solemn rituals, and generous hospitality, along with a stubbornness that refuses to retreat easily. I walked through empty valleys and heard young shepherds talk of distant holy lands, their eyes gleaming in the moonlight; inside them was a faith in ultimate justice, an expectation of divine judgment, and a longing for the grievances of this life to be washed away in the next world.
Compared to a culture that finds its return in "The One," Chinese civilization is more like a thick clay accustomed to compromise and harmony, allowing for multiple gods and ancestors to coexist. It permits Confucianism, Buddhism, and Taoism to layer upon each other, allowing ancestral tablets to sit alongside abstract concepts. So when the two meet, tensions inevitably arise at certain points: one emphasizes absolute truth, the other is used to diversity; one emphasizes commandments, the other trusts more in human sentiment. But what I saw on the Northwest Loess Plateau was another scene entirely—the two cultures avoiding direct collision, choosing instead to live quietly side-by-side in daily life.
I still remember those times in the residual snow of Xihaigu when people gathered for the collective visiting of graves. The loess ridge was all white, and people gathered from every direction; white headscarves fluttered in the wind, and the repressed historical memories in their chests were awakened by unified movements and sounds. It was a belief forged through tragic events and the cost of blood, a spiritual history rarely written about head-on in mainstream textbooks. Every major religion in the world has been embroiled in power and violence in some way, but in the daily lives of these grassroots believers, faith acts more like a rope that pulls people out of failure and poverty, allowing them to keep a shred of dignity in extreme hardship.
Crossing the Tianshan Mountains, I heard ballads on the grasslands that blended Islamic and nomadic traditions. Under the vast sky, the stars were cold; human voices blended with drumbeats, and saddles and sandalwood paperweights bore witness to time sinking suffering into the internal textures of the soul. The modern World-Systems theory loves to talk about "center-periphery," placing the Islamic world and many parts of Africa and Latin America at the exploited end, discussing economics, resources, and trade structures. Structurally, these points have merit, but I always feel they can't fully capture the soul of a people.
In that vastness, I felt another confrontation: facing the single-path narrative represented by the West, those civilizations classified as "the periphery" are silently maintaining a different cosmic order with their own scriptures, drumbeats, and desolate graves on the loess soil.
The wind of Western culture has been blowing across the seas and into our continent for a long time.
Books tell me its core is reason, science, the individual, and rights—a whole set of cognitive methods supported by empiricism, laboratories, and mathematical models. As anthropologists lament the disintegration of traditional societies, young people in many places have already learned to use this logic to explain the world: the world can be precisely measured, history can be pushed linearly, and the individual is a self-sufficient unit that can separate from family and the earth, connecting with others solely through contracts and law.
I don't deny the value of these achievements. Modern natural science has liberated many from disease and hunger, peeled back the structure of the universe bit by bit, and stripped away layers of human cognitive bias. Interdisciplinary research in cognitive psychology, cultural neuroscience, and anthropology allows us to see that people in different cultures truly leave traces in their brains regarding their understanding of self, groups, and fairness. These findings help us recognize differences more calmly and stop easily judging entire civilizations as "superior" or "inferior."
The problem arises when this way of explaining the world is absolutized by some, treated as the only yardstick, and the richness of other civilizations is compressed into being "pre-modern" or "backward." World-systems theorists, post-colonial scholars, and researchers of civilizational diversity have spent decades deconstructing this single-line theory. They tell us that Western modernity is also a specific historical path, the result of a specific geography, religion, and economic structure, rather than a universal template that everyone must follow.
Standing on the banks of a river in the North as the ice began to break, I spent a long time thinking about this. As the ice on the river started to shift, water came roaring up from underneath, pushing the jagged chunks aside, and when the sunlight hit it, the surface glistened. In that moment, I knew clearly: if any one culture on this planet claims the title of 'modern' exclusively, leaving no room for other civilizations to speak, that is a dangerous kind of poverty.
Western culture offers a powerful toolkit—scientific methods, institutional design, human rights discourse, and democratic ideals. These are things countries across the globe can selectively borrow to improve their lives, build fairer societies, and protect human dignity. But it cannot, and should not, erase the depth of the Chinese loess plateau, the devotion found in Islamic scriptures, or the rhythm of life in African drumbeats.
When I think of African culture, I’m reminded of a young man I met in the borderlands who had just returned from his studies in Africa. At a snowy outpost, he told me about grasslands beyond the ones I knew—where the grass is greener, the sky is bluer, and cattle and drumbeats interweave by evening campfires. He talked about village elders, market chants, the patterns painted on skin during rituals, and how they navigate between the memory of colonialism and the hope for the future. Anthropologists have long listened to those voices in the forests and the Sahel region of Africa, documenting oral histories, myths, and kinship systems, while reflecting on the arrogance that once used evolutionary theories to hold others down.
For a long time, the true depth of African civilization was misunderstood by the world. Some media outlets only like to focus on war, disease, and poverty as the main themes, occasionally tossing in a shallow nod to 'primitive joy.' This kind of narrative is neither fair nor serious. Later scholarship has begun to correct this, highlighting the complexity of Africa's diverse ethnic groups, languages, and religions, emphasizing the wisdom in oral traditions, and focusing on ethics centered on the collective and a deep sensitivity to natural rhythms.
Behind those words, I always picture another scene I’ve seen on the grasslands of the Northwest: the withering and flourishing of wild grass, the movement of groups, the blending of drumbeats and horse hooves, where people feel as much like dust as they do sparks of fire. The dancing of African people under the scorching sun and the rhythm of their drums aren't so different in spirit from the long, flowing folk songs of our Northern grasslands, the drumbeats of Central Asia, or the dua (supplication/prayer) of the Arab world. They are all humanity’s shared response to the earth, to life, and to death—using the body to remember and rhythm to face an unknowable fate.
Thinking about this amid the heavy snowfall in the Liupan Mountains, a rough map of the human spirit began to unfold in my mind.
Chinese civilization is like a great loess mountain—topped with residual snow, rooted in ancient graves; the legal and ritual codes are like layers of stacked earth, with scriptures buried alongside farming tools. Islamic civilization is like a river flowing from a sea of sand, lingering near the snow line, carrying a strict rhythm that washes away human desires again and again, teaching people to find freedom within discipline. Western civilization is like a machine that is constantly self-deconstructing and reassembling, skilled at looking at itself with skepticism, upgrading its tools, and measuring the world with precision. African culture is like a grassland panting in the heat: the surface is all dance and song, but underneath lies a profound, lingering trauma and resilience, rising again and again after being beaten down, using the rhythm of the body to mend the cracks left by history.
These labels have their limitations, but I’m no longer interested in swapping them for fancier terms. Academia already has too many complex concepts: dialogue of civilizations, multiple modernities, post-colonial context, cultural psychological structures... these words have their place, and I’ve been inspired by them too. But standing at the doorway of a mud house in Xihaigu, watching black goats forage for grass on the edge of the snow above an old cave dwelling, I trust the simplest judgment more—every civilization has tempered its bones in extreme environments and has its own way of upholding human dignity.
The problem isn't the differences themselves; the problem is the arrogance.
The pattern of the world’s mainstream culture isn't a fixed table; it’s a flowing river. The Chinese, Islamic, Western, and African traditions have all been pushed to the center or the margins at different points in history. In our era, technology and capital make information move fast, making some discourses easy to amplify and other voices easy to drown out. The media loves chasing the 'mainstream' label, as if whatever is mentioned most often is the core, while the quiet, the patient, and the remote can be ignored.
Having stood before the abandoned graves in Xihaigu for a long time, another bottom line formed in my heart: what defines a civilization shouldn't be its volume, but how it treats its weakest members. Whether the most marginalized people in a culture—the poor, the sick, minorities, the downtrodden—can still maintain basic dignity and aren't treated as disposable, that is the true litmus test.
Chinese civilization uses patriarchal clans and local community bonds to weave the isolated individual into a network of kinship and geography; even if it’s rudimentary, it provides them with a meal and a place to stand. Islamic doctrine, through almsgiving and communal dua, allows the most impoverished to find their place within the collective. Western rights discourse uses institutions to build defenses for the weak; though imperfect, it at least establishes a standard to hold power publicly accountable. African village traditions use sharing and festivals to let those living through famine and war catch their breath within the rhythm of the group.
None of these approaches are pure; all carry the risk of being co-opted by power or swallowed by the market. Yet, in the wind and snow of the Liupan Mountains, under the dim light of a mud house, in the long winds of the grasslands, and among the drumbeats at the intersection of forest and desert, I still choose to believe in a stubborn, cleansing spirit that appears in different civilizations under different names, resisting the cold tendency to treat human beings as mere tools or numbers.
I walk along the long mountain road, the ground beneath my feet frozen hard, the path ahead rising in segments. Behind me is the heavy memory this land has pressed upon me; in front of me is a world surrounded by all sorts of 'mainstream' terminology.
How to understand the world’s mainstream culture is a question that, for many who call themselves intellectuals, easily becomes a word game. They move concepts around in their studies and rank the superiority of civilizations in lecture halls, talking about tolerance and dialogue while their eyes are often clouded with the arrogance of perspective. I don't want to repeat their path.
I would rather respond in a slower way: walking on the loess mountains, standing by the residual snow in Xihaigu, listening to the night wind in a mud house, touching the damp earth in front of a weathered cave dwelling, and then bringing the theories of distant civilizations, small experimental data, and those so-called cutting-edge theories, one by one, to this place—setting them on the earthen kang (heated brick bed) and beside the lonely graves, just to see how much weight they truly hold.
Perhaps in the end, I will only get some blurry answers:
Chinese civilization teaches me that a person must have a sense of shame; even if you're so poor that all you have left is rags, you must hold onto a bottom line that cannot be sold. Islamic civilization reminds me that there are judgments in this world higher than the pursuit of a livelihood, and beliefs more stable than current power; one should not forget the longing for ultimate justice. Western civilization forces me to learn how to doubt myself, to use the light of reason to illuminate blind faith, to restrain power with institutions, and to reflect on prejudices with science. African culture, meanwhile, helps me remember that the movement of the body and the drumbeat of the collective can carry trauma, that memory isn't just found on paper, and dignity isn't maintained by words alone.
These realizations are rough and unsystematic; they wouldn't hold up in an academic debate. But I am willing to stand by them because they were gained through walking, honed bit by bit in the wind and snow, on the loess soil, and before the residual snow on abandoned graves.
I head back from the snowy road of the Liupan Mountains as twilight approaches. The black goats on the ridge are being herded into their pens, the waning moon hangs higher, and a faint, dim yellow light filters through the cracks in the mud cottage windows. The snow on the old graves grows deeper, the shadows of the crumbling cave dwellings grow darker, and the wind circles the earthen slopes.
The world's mainstream culture is debating in far-off places, shouting slogans in conference halls, on the internet, and on paper. I cannot hear those echoes; I only hear the silence emanating from the ground beneath my feet.
Perhaps one day, when these four winds blow harder, and more children hold books from distant lands in their hands, learning the languages of other places through screens, they will understand the big words—Chinese, Islamic, Western, African—in new ways, finding more precise explanations in new laboratories and fields. I am no longer young, and I won't be around for that final conclusion.
All I can do is write down these feelings from the loess today and pass them on to those younger than me.
When that time comes, if they happen to pass through the Liupan Mountains in the deep snow, walk past the mud houses, and weave between the black goats on the ridge and the snow-covered graves, they might suddenly feel a touch of hesitation: when faced with the glittering mainstream of the distant world, how should one place one's own steps? How to be neither kneeling nor drawing a sword? How to be neither inferior nor blindly arrogant?
If they find themselves stuck with this question, then I will know that this long mountain road was not walked in vain.