Hui Muslim Villages in Northwest China: Modernization, Education, and Islamic Heritage on the Loess Plateau
Spotlighting the Hui Muslim villages in the Northwest Loess Plateau following the complete victory over poverty alleviation. Beyond material upgrades like smooth roads and brand-new houses, we take a deep dive into deeper developmental issues such as expanding the horizons of rural youth, catching up with modern education, and cultural-psychological adaptation.
I always remember the first time I climbed over that massive mountain—the sky was still gray, and the wind blowing in from far away pressed the dry, cold vibe of the Northwest right against my face, leaving nothing in my throat but the earthy taste of dust. Ridge after ridge of parched, barren earth stacked on top of each other like long-sun-dried bones. Standing on the mountain ridge, deep ravines stretched out beneath my feet like someone had jammed their fingers deep into the loess mud and clawed it up, leaving the earth full of cracks.
Later on, I found out people gave this place a heavy name, calling it "the most bitter and barren place under heaven," and spent decades driving poverty out inch by inch, changing the face of the harshest days on the Loess Plateau. But when I was climbing that slope that day, I didn't know any of that yet. I was just crying from the wind, with a vague feeling in my heart: if no one watches over parched loess like this, would it get blown completely empty by the wind one day, taking the memory of an entire ethnic group along with it?
The road was super narrow, and before the snow hit, it still showed its cracked, yellowish face. There weren't many trees down in the ravine, and they all looked like they’d been trimmed by the wind—their branches crooked and tilted off to one side. Seen from afar, they looked like a squad of soldiers marching sideways against the wind. A layer of dark clouds pressed down on the edge of the sky, and lingering snow still hung on the back of the mountains from last winter, not fully melted, hiding on the shady slopes like a bunch of grayish-white scars.
With my backpack on, I walked deeper into the ravine, the soles of my shoes scraping against the hardened lumps of mud and making a crisp sound, keeping time with my footsteps as they tapped right against my heart. Some people say once this loess gets into your eyes, it takes root in your heart, and no matter how many years you leave and talk about the scenery elsewhere, your dreams will always bring you back to these ravines. Back then, I didn't really believe it—people gotta venture out a bit, right? The world is so huge, who’s gonna constantly obsess over a barren patch of dirt? But as I kept walking, I started doubting myself.
On that sloping hillside halfway up the mountain, goats were scattered among the withered grass, heads down, patiently searching the practically green-free dirt for anything they could chew on. When the wind blew, the goats' wool sloped down with the terrain, looking from afar like bundles of shadows bent over by the wind. They're used to this kind of life, just like the people here—used to the drought, used to the sandstorms, used to spending their whole lives circling the mountain ridges, stepping all over the old paths worn down by their ancestors.
I stood by the side of the road, watching those few goats closest to me. One of them looked up and glared at me, its pupils pitch-black and shining, then slowly lowered its head again, sticking its muzzle toward the frozen grass roots right by its hooves. At that moment, I always felt like an extra, like someone crashing some silent ritual and disrupting an order that should've just grown and withered all on its own.
Walking deep into the ravine, the road got even narrower, and the steep loess cliffs on both sides pressed the sky down really low. When you looked up, you only saw a thin ribbon of sky. In this kind of terrain, sounds get easily muffled; even if someone yells from ahead, the echo comes across dull and hoarse. Once a big snow seals off the mountains, this place turns into a semi-closed world made up of just loess, black rocks, a few old cave-dwelling entrances, and wandering silhouettes.
That row of rundown cave dwellings leaned right against the carved-out hillside, plastered outside with years of wind and frost as flakes of mud peeled off, but the entrances still kept a smooth curve without collapsing, looking like an old eye staring at visitors from the shadows. Right next to the cave dwellings were low-slung yellow-mud houses with thin walls stained dark brown by smoke. Strings of firewood hung drying under the eaves, rustling in the wind. When the wooden door creaked open, that tiny bit of light inside would spill out like a faint glow from the bottom of a well—not illuminating much, but enough for a family on a winter night to huddle together by the edge of the brick bed (*kang*) to keep warm in silence.
The first time I stepped into an adobe house like this was on an afternoon chilled right down to the bones. Bits of flurries started drifting across the mountain ridge—the ground hadn't turned white yet, but the air had already gotten damp and cold. A local opened the door a crack and told me to hurry inside, saying the wind was howling outside and I shouldn't just stand there freezing. There wasn't much light inside; just a dim little yellow lamp in the corner with oil smoke clinging to the walls and creeping upward, painting the ceiling dark. Sitting on the edge of the *kang* was an old man with washed-out clothes and frayed cuffs. Hearing the door, he turned his head, and the deep calm in his eyes instantly made me too embarrassed to say any polite fluff.
I always suspected that all those academic terms and theories I learned elsewhere became way too light when brought into this room—so light I almost felt ashamed to speak them aloud. When you toss around mouthfuls of clunky buzzwords like "development," "structure," and "transition," it feels like a gust of wind sweeping across the loess surface. Once the wind stops, the dirt is still the same dirt, the people are still the same people, and that patchworked-to-death cotton quilt on the *kang* remains their absolute shield against the cold winter nights.
I sat on the edge of the *kang*, running one hand over that coarse quilt cover where the thread ends felt prickly, while holding a bowl of piping hot water in the other. They call this kind of water "pot tea (*guanguan cha*)," though it really just has a faint tint and barely any taste. Yet on an afternoon like that, with a body chilled straight through by the wind, leaning against the corner of the *kang* and holding that bowl of warm water, it honestly felt like being treated kindly by the world. There weren't many people in the room, and they didn't talk much either—ask a question, get an answer, and for the most part, just sit in silence.
I spotted an old trunk leaning against the corner of their wall, with a heavily thumbed book resting on top of it. Its paper corners were curled up, and the printed characters on the cover were worn so blurry you couldn't tell what it was. The old man reached out and pressed down on that book, as if afraid I might accidentally touch it, and said softly that this was something left behind by the older generations—no matter how worn out it looked, it still had to be kept safe. There was a kind of unspeakable reverence in that tone, like submission to some unseen order.
Inside a house like this, I suddenly felt that a lot of outside preconceptions about "Hui Muslims" were way too simple and reckless. Some folks love flattening an entire ethnic group with a few generalized labels, making it seem like they all share one uniform face and a single destiny. But sitting on the edge of the mud-brick house's *kang*, I was facing real, individual human beings—their wrinkles, the cracked skin on the backs of their hands, the little savings they secretly hid under their pillows, their strict adherence to halal food (*qingshen yinshi*), and the lifelong code they refused to compromise. That silent persistence didn't feel like a slogan; it felt more like a heavy stone pressing down on your chest, making you afraid to let your mind wander.
I’ve hiked through quite a few villages, from the flat plains along the northern river to the depths of these Loess Mountains. According to statistics, people have long analyzed this ethnic group's gaps in education years and asset accumulation, while marveling at how they've caught up in income—and even surpassed some neighboring villages—through migrant work and business. Numbers matter; they tell people poverty isn't an eternal curse, and they help outsiders realize that so-called "hardship" isn't just a single column in an income ledger.
Yet walking along those long mountain roads, watching squads of young people hauling backpacks as they rushed out from the ravines, I'd rather view these "gaps" and "remedies" as that inner restlessness and grit forged by hard times. Plenty of studies have written about how young Hui Muslims from these places travel far, work hard, send money back home, and bring new lifestyles and perspectives back to the village. In statistical charts, this is migration and structural adjustment; down in the loess ravines, it feels more like a series of silent journeys: some people root themselves elsewhere forever, while others make the trip back and forth repeatedly, their footsteps worn painfully raw between two different worlds.
I always notice how the land and faith weave together here into a very distinct weight. People say Hui Muslims have a strong cultural and traditional visibility, yet in language, clothing, and working styles, they are tightly intertwined with the majority groups around them. This state of being both close and distant brings a sense of flexibility and ease in cities or multi-ethnic urban neighborhoods, but out here in the loess ravines, it feels more like walking a tightrope trapped between two cliff faces: getting super close to either side while always keeping a tiny slit open that nobody can squeeze through entirely.
The Loess Mountains are their backing, packed tight and hard like stone, and those mountain-sealing snowstorms are an annual test. When the snow falls over around Mount Liupan, the entire mountain range sinks into a blanket of white; roads at the bottom of the ravines get cut off, vehicles stall halfway, and only human silhouettes inch forward step by step in the snow. Snow presses down on low walls, on abandoned graves, and at the cave entrances, glaringly white. Standing in the snow, you feel completely cut off from the world by a layer of insulation—sound, color, and scent all sink away, leaving only the crisp crunching sound right under your feet to remind you that you're still alive on this earth.
One winter, I looped around the Mount Liupan area, gradually closing in on the depths of the loess as the snow waxed and waned and the sky shifted between bright and dark. The old cotton jacket on my back grew increasingly heavy, like I was carrying some invisible burden. Along the road, I saw mounds of abandoned graves with soil covered unevenly by snow, the wind blowing the snow into disarray to reveal patches of withered grass and scattered stone fragments. There were no tombstones, or if there were, the wind and frost had worn away the inscriptions. Only the mountain knows how many generations have been buried right inside its embrace.
I always remember a snow-soaked path right next to an abandoned tomb. A companion traveling with me said that plenty of people used to come here back in the day; on special occasions, folks from all over the ravines would walk over, stand in silent reverence before the forgotten graves, recite prayers (*dua*), and keep those names passed down by word of mouth securely in their hearts. Later on, as conditions improved, villagers moved into better relocation settlements with brand-new houses and smoother roads, living cozier lives. Fewer and fewer people visited the old graves in the ravine, save for howling snowstorms where silhouettes still seemed to slowly bend over that ring of loess earth.
That is another dimension deep within the history of this ethnic group. In official history books, accounts of them are mostly dry events noting some war, some migration, some policy, or some administrative setup, brushed past lightly. Yet sleeping inside these loess-mounded graves is a different kind of memory: stories about suffering, perseverance, and those who paid with their lives to uphold their faith through different eras. Countless names were forgotten long ago, and countless stories have been worn smooth by the passage of time, leaving only a single piece of advice passed down through generations: stay pure, follow the rules, and live up to your own inner moral compass in the smallest everyday moments.
I’ve listened to plenty of elders talk about the old days, sharing tales of ancestral exile, endurance during even tougher times, and how they gritted their teeth to share a mouthful of dry rations with someone even hungrier during famine years. When recounting these things, they never put hardship on the tip of their tongue; they'd just say flatly, "Those times were tough, ah," and stop right there, casting their gaze toward some distant mountain slope outside the window. I've seen that gesture of looking away in many places—across different ethnic groups and different villages, people have an almost instinctive avoidance when talking about suffering, as if speaking too much turns it into some kind of bargaining chip. Yet on this loess soil, that avoidance carries an extra layer of meaning: they refuse to talk about hardship to people who don't understand, and they won't let shallow ears casually brush against memories that are far too heavy.
In quite a few sociological and ethnographic studies, researchers have already laid this out clearly: how village Hui Muslims found a way out through the nation's targeted poverty alleviation policies, how they rely on education to improve their next generation's future, and how they transformed their family income structures through migrant work and specialized local industries. These writings bring me peace of mind because they prove that this ethnic group's place in the grand scheme is no longer forgotten in a corner, but is being genuinely seen and supported. The Loess Mountains are no longer an isolated backwater, but an important coordinate on the map of development.
Yet when I stood on the Mount Liupan ridge again, left speechless by the biting wind, my heart was still gently twisted by a more hidden kind of anxiety. This worry isn't aimed at any policy or any specific person, but rather at that easily overlooked spot deep within human hearts: when material hardships are chipped away layer by layer, when paved roads reach the mountaintops, and when children step out of the ravines into a broader world, will that "clean spirit" once nurtured by this ethnic group through suffering also gradually get blunted by the noise of the market and the calculations of reality?
Stepping into a village school, I saw brightly colored drawings and slogans pasted on the walls, with crisp, clear reading aloud echoing from the classrooms. The children's faces were clean, and their eyes shone bright—not all that different from kids in city schools. During recess, a little boy hurried over to ask me if the outside world was really huge, with super tall buildings and bustling streets. He said that once he made it out of the mountains, he wanted to see the ocean. At that exact moment, my heart was filled with joy. Kids in the ravines having that kind of vision means they are no longer trapped in a closed mindset; they know there are other views and other paths in life beyond the mountains.
Yet in another corner, I also saw other kids who, at such a young age, are already way too good at calculating things in front of adults—talking about whose family went South to work, making more money, sending back more cash, building a new house, buying better appliances, and so on. He talked with total earnestness, and there was no malice in his eyes; it’s just that they learned way too early to measure everything by income. In modern society, that’s a skill, an adaptation, an active way of grasping reality. But at that exact moment, a sudden sense of melancholy washed over me—wondering if those simple values once passed down in cave dwellings, by the kang (heated brick bed), inside the mosque, and through the elders' chanting would quietly get swapped out in their generation for a much more realistic ledger.
The word "struggle" has never been one-dimensional for Hui Muslims; it's just that in the past, the weight of it pressed mostly on material survival. Down in the arid Loess Plateau, inside water-scarce mountain ravines, and across traffic-isolated villages, they scraped by just for a sip of water, a patch of land, and a bag of grain. Over the years, thanks to deep-reaching government poverty alleviation efforts, infrastructure upgrades, and ecological migration relocations, absolute poverty in many places has been completely rewritten. The cold statistics sit right there: those counties and townships once designated as key poverty-stricken areas have shed their "poverty" labels one by one. New villages are scattered along the foot of the mountains, streetlights turn on at night, and medical insurance, education, and social security have woven people's lives into a much more secure net.
New struggles are slowly bubbling up from elsewhere. It’s the subtle friction between identity and modern lifestyles, the tug-of-war between traditional faith and secular rhythms, and the question of how to fit in without losing your roots in a multi-ethnic urban space. These issues don’t just belong to Hui Muslims—they belong to all rural folks moving to the cities, and to everyone swept along by the currents of modernization. It’s just that for an ethnic group with such distinct religious and cultural traits, these questions feel a bit sharper.
In neighborhoods on the outskirts of major cities, I’ve seen Hui Muslim youth bustling about—some running shops, some working in the service industry, and others bouncing between construction sites and factories. Compared to their peers in more remote areas, their incomes aren't low, and their horizons are broader. Studies show that urban employment for Hui Muslims in many places is no longer limited to a single industry; with better education and social security coverage, their quality of life has noticeably improved. Yet when I chat casually with some of them, I can still hear them softly mention an indescribable pressure: trying to juggle the fast-paced city life while keeping household religious rules, dealing with people from all walks of life, and quietly defending their own names and origins deep down inside.
They won’t share these feelings with just anyone. It’s usually late at night, or right after a meal, when someone suddenly blurts out: "Sometimes I feel like I don't even know where I belong." As soon as the words are out, they pull them right back, laugh it off, and say that as long as life is good, everyone has their struggles—it's not just us. Hearing this, I know it isn't really a "contradiction" or a conflict, but rather a widespread identity wobbling in a rapidly changing era. It just feels a bit more intricate and harder to put into words when it lands on a group carrying such unique historical memories.
I’ve always felt that the true struggle for Hui Muslims, in the long run, isn’t just about being "poor," but about "what gets remembered." In those mud-brick houses on the Loess Plateau, and amidst the low whispers beside desolate graves and residual snow, there flows an unpretentious spiritual thread. It doesn't like loud preaching, nor is it used to performing on stages; it reveals itself only in the tiniest gestures of everyday people—the brief moment of solemnity right before a meal, a promise made that will never be broken, the careful weighing of goods in a trade, and the restraint and forbearance shown when misunderstood.
These things are hard to quantify and tough for outsiders to see clearly. Some call it "cleanliness," while others don't name it at all, simply saying, "That’s how our family lives." Even after moving out of the old village, even after living in apartment buildings, and even when kids go off to school in distant cities, these habits secretly tag along—hidden beside the dinner table, tucked away in the glow of a holiday lamp, or lingering in an elder's imperceptible sigh.
I once stood for a long time in a newly built migration village. The houses there are neatly planned, with paved concrete roads running right up to everyone’s doorstep, neatly stacked firewood in the courtyards, and newly planted saplings. In the open space at the entrance of the village, a few elderly folks sat in the sunlight, soaking up the warmth and chatting. From afar, these scenes look no different from many new rural villages in China's interior. But walk a bit closer, and you can tell from the women's headscarves and the men's ways of greeting that this village holds onto its own traditions.
I chatted with a middle-aged man for a bit, and he told me that moving out was a good thing. The mountain gullies were a dead end with severe soil erosion, where farming an acre barely yielded a few bushels of grain. People kept trickling away, leaving mostly the old and the young behind. Now that they’ve moved here, the land has been consolidated and managed, water conservancy projects are in place, sending kids to school is easier, and seeing a doctor is more convenient—life is way better than before. At that point, he paused and added: it’s just that the graveyard is back there, and the mosque is back there too. During the holidays, we still have to go back and take a look. At that moment, I felt like I saw an invisible thread stretching from the clean streets of the new village all the way back to that old land deep in the loess hills, tying two different eras and two different lifestyles together.
I often suspect that these projects rolled out by the state in ethnic minority regions—poverty alleviation, relocation, infrastructure, education, and public health—while superficially changing living conditions, are actually reshaping the relationship between people and the land. The struggle of Hui Muslims in the vast loess mountains has been a generations-long dance with barrenness, a way to maintain the dignity and identity of a group in an environment lagging in economic development. Coming to today, when the label of absolute poverty has been stripped away, when traveling around is no longer a hassle, when kids have the chance to finish middle school and go to college, and when Halal food is much more easily guaranteed in many places, a much wider path has opened up before this ethnic group.
Yet precisely at a time like this, I dare not easily say that "the struggle is over." Some struggles are historical and material; step-by-step, policies, investments, and resource pooling can resolve them. Other struggles are spiritual—hovering between collective memory and realistic desires, between maintaining cleanliness and facing vulgarity, and between standing tall to live or learning to bend just to make life a bit more comfortable. There’s no simple right or wrong to these dilemmas, and outsiders shouldn't rush to judge them. They belong entirely to everyone standing on that loess soil, left for them to choose.
Along the road, I often think of those desolate graves and residual snow. When the wind blows over from Liupan Mountain, snowflakes whip through the air, hitting your face and slipping inside your collar. The black goats on the ridge keep their heads down searching for food on the dirt slopes, the old trees in front of the cave dwellings keep bending in the wind, and people walking along the mountain paths leave very shallow footprints that are wiped away by the new wind and snow in the blink of an eye. The world is moving, but the earth has its own slow rhythm. It’s not in a rush; it sees things through the long haul, having witnessed harder days, and it will witness brighter years ahead.
The struggles of Hui Muslims are, after all, not an isolated topic. They must be placed within the development history of the entire country, along the path a multi-ethnic nation travels together, inside those unremarkable little villages, and amidst the bustling figures working under the dim streetlights of big cities. The hardships this ethnic group once carried have been drastically lightened through rounds of support policies, batches of resident village cadres, and the self-driven efforts of generations—that’s reality, not empty talk. What they must face in the future is how to maintain their grit and cleanliness while enjoying a greater sense of security, without romanticizing suffering or turning sacrifice into a slogan, yet without losing the backbone polished by harsh winds.
Sometimes, I wake up in the middle of the night, and my mind pictures a long mountain road. On both sides are parched loess gullies, the distant ridges of Liupan Mountain are capped with a thin layer of snow, and a crescent moon hangs in the sky, casting a faint, cold light over the roofs of the mud-brick houses. A single figure is on the road, carrying a backpack and moving forward step by step. That person looks both like me from years ago and like countless young people who walked out of the mountains yet constantly look back toward them in their hearts.
I don't know which city, dock, or factory this road leads to, nor do I know how this person will navigate the balance between multiple identities in the days to come. Maybe one morning, standing by a high-rise window, he’ll suddenly think of the oil lamp on his grandmother's kang, feel a sting in his nose, and then turn away with a smile; or maybe one evening, bringing his own kids back to the old village, he’ll stand before the desolate graves for a while, not saying much, just whispering quietly in his heart: We still remember.
I’ve crossed vast wildernesses, witnessed life and death, and fancied myself as someone who understands a bit of hardship and sees through worldly vanity. Yet I still dare not make a light judgment for any ethnic group, defining what their struggles are or what their way out should be. All I can do is treat myself as a traveler on the road, slowly writing down the loess under my feet, the black goats, the dilapidated cave dwellings, the desolate graves under residual snow, and the heavy mountain blizzards right before my eyes.
Maybe many years from now, when we look back at today, we’ll realize that this era itself is a fragment of a "struggle." Developing so fast and changing so fiercely, people's hearts can barely keep up with the speed. When we ask back then: deep in the Loess Plateau, across those parched ravines in the Northwest, and between the cave dwellings and new villages where generations of Hui Muslims have lived, what did we actually leave behind, and what did we accidentally lose along the way?
I don't have a ready-made answer, knowing only that this very question mark is perhaps a form of relatively sober memory. Whoever can hold onto that question mark a bit longer manages to keep just a little bit of their own roots alive in a noisy world. The struggles of Hui Muslims will perhaps slowly transform from a heavy burden into a quiet self-awareness, quietly continuing against the vast and expansive backdrop of mountains and rivers.