Deconstructing Islamic Civilization: An Authentic Look at Faith, History, and Human Contribution in Northwest China
We’re diving deep to break down the common biases and stereotypical questions circulating in public discourse. By blending everyday observations of life in Northwest China with facts from global history, we’re looking at the real face of Islamic faith—a tradition that values peace, integrity in business, knowledge transmission, and moral self-discipline.
I
In the driest stretch of the northern season, I hit that long, diagonal road leading southwest again. The loess soil was buffed shiny by the wind, and the ravines looked like endless old scars. Behind the car window, I eventually left the vehicle behind at the fifteen-kilometer marker—past the foot-pedicure shops, past the familiar wooden canes—and headed down a dirt track that quietly snaked its way deep into the mountain ridges.
The wind whipped over from the Liupan Mountains, carrying the metallic scent of snow. Even before the white stuff actually started falling, the mountains were already huddled in grey. The black goats were pressed against the ridge early on, looking like stubborn black ink strokes permanently etched onto a parchment of loess, refusing to budge.
I knew that just a few mountain bends ahead lay that stretch of scorched, parched loess gullies everyone talks about. In every nook and cranny, the yellow mud houses and dilapidated cave dwellings were huffing out smoke, passing every family’s hopes and grievances bit by bit up into the sky.
The outside world has given this place plenty of names—some based on my own identity, some born from misunderstandings, and many more simply slapped on with lazy, insulting labels like backward or ignorant. People slap these stickers on and walk away, never actually bothering with the truth.
Standing in the wind, looking at the white dots appearing and disappearing in the gullies, I knew those weren't rocks. They were lingering snow on forgotten graves—remnants of lives lived by people whose names never made it into the history books, yet who staked their entire existence on this land.
For years, I’ve heard a simplistic narrative: that this faith, which arrived from the horizon in the West, only brought hatred, division, and harm to the nation and its civilization.
I walked downhill, the frozen loess crunching and brittle under my boots. With every squeak of my cleats, I couldn’t stop asking myself a core question: What is it, exactly, that makes up this so-called harm on this silent plateau? Is it the faith itself, the doctrine, the way they perform dua (prayer), or is it just that little part of the human heart that’s been warped by the wind?
II
The snow arrived abruptly, much like the sudden gusts of wind that have blown through different eras, freezing the loess solid before anyone could even react.
I walked slowly through the blizzard. Ahead, there was a ridge of yellow earth where a few goats were half-buried in the drift, their beards covered in ice shards. They watched me quietly, never questioning any theories from far away, nor asking how modern science evaluates the destiny of their lives.
Goats are the old-timers of these mountains, while people are just fascinated by passersby—like me, a book-learned visitor, just another gust of wind.
The snow blurred every detail into shades of grey, leaving only the indentations visible: the mouths of cave dwellings, the narrow edges of the kang (heated brick bed), and the places where people have knelt and bowed.
By the time I stepped into a mud house, the snow had already sealed the threshold.
An old man and his wife were sitting on the kang, and an iron pot in the corner was bubbling away with a rhythmic thumping sound. The walls were yellow, stained black by years of smoke. A few crooked rafters pressed down on the ceiling, topped with a layer of yellow mud, which was now blanketed in snow.
They were dressed in white, their clothes patched up. The roughness on their faces, carved by the bitter wind, was a clearer map of Xihaigu than any atlas could provide.
When I sat by the fire, the room was quiet, save for the sound of boiling water. Sensing my sudden appearance, the old man looked up at me, his gaze drifting past my shoulder as if looking right through the earthen wall toward the distant mountain ridge.
What is it you study? he asked.
I just blurted out that I study people, faith, and how this rugged plateau grinds a person's heart down until it becomes what it is today.
He smiled, revealing a gap between his teeth. When you're hungry, you pray to Allah; when the snow blocks the door, you pray for a path to open; when a child is sick, you pray for them to survive. There is nothing else.
He doesn’t use academic jargon like religion or institution. He only recognizes that blackened spot on the wall of his room, where he bows and rises again every morning and evening.
In a lot of modern studies, those repeated movements have names and elaborate theories. They claim rituals shape groups, that people who kneel together find it easier to treat their own as family, and that this subtle psychological mechanism can both gather power and easily transform into something rigid.
Scholars carefully write in their papers: A highly uniform identity, when resources are tight and information is imbalanced, can amplify the risk of conflict and create social costs that need to be neutralized through education, public services, and national laws.
Sitting on the corner of the kang, watching the old man slowly get up to face the wall—bowing and kneeling in a lifelong, imperfect sequence, his forehead gently tapping against the black shadow—I suddenly felt that all those big words like group, conflict, and identity politics were nothing compared to the hardened skin on his forehead, which provided a much more honest answer to life on this land.
III
All that airy, dismissive talk about how a certain faith brings nothing but harm to China—claiming it’s inherently at odds with the country or unwilling to integrate into mainstream society—sounds so confident from the outside. But here in this tiny mud hut, those ideas vanish like a spark hitting a puddle of water.
The old man’s entire life has been stuck in these parched, yellow earthen gullies. He doesn’t know world maps, only narrow, winding goat paths. He doesn’t see history as grand national narratives, but as stories of who lent someone grain during a lean year or which generation gave their own rations to a neighbor during a famine.
To the cognitive anthropologists, his "De-men" (religious path/faith) is likely just a set of stories that anchor an individual within a group—a way of teaching people to believe in the significance of self-sacrifice.
But he wouldn’t understand those academic terms.
He only knows that back in his grandfather’s generation, during a winter when men returned from beyond the mountains, they brought back humiliation and heavy memories of martyrdom. Under the thick snow, how many bones died simply for a "Doli" (a principle or moral truth)?
Traces of a past generation, quietly buried under the cold, drifted snow of forgotten graves.
History books love to document the battles of royal courts and the shifting of city rulers; they rarely spare space for the invisible deaths in these narrow, deep-cut valleys. Sociology offers a cold judgment, too, claiming that such sacrifices in grand narratives are mostly the result of "structural systems"—a forced price paid amidst clashing identities.
Those theoretical judgments on paper have their points.
But when you’re trudging through heavy mountain snow and see those rings of crumbled stone on the ridge, the snow pressing down on your heart like an elder’s bared white teeth, you realize clearly: those so-called "costs" were people with names, mothers, wives, and children. They were people who had recited scripture in the glow of a kiln fire and shared secret smiles with their kids.
To say that "religion has brought harm to China" feels incredibly shallow and reckless in a place like this.
What really cuts into these hillsides was never the scripture itself. It’s when those scriptures are forcibly ripped from the earth and twisted into angry roars, political banners, and rigid walls to divide people. That kind of groundless, fanatical extremism is what slowly erodes this yellow soil.
IV
Watching this film, I see so many gaps—not just geographical ones, but those held in the heart.
Scientific studies love to throw around strings of numbers, citing how this region ranked low in national per-capita indicators, pointing to childhood malnutrition, high infant mortality, and fragile ecology.
Numbers, they call it—just preliminary data.
But sitting by the edge of a "kang" (traditional heated brick bed), poverty isn’t a number. It’s hands frozen bright red, it’s a piece of hard, dry "mo" (steamed bread) hanging from a mud ceiling, it’s shivering in the gale at the mouth of a cave dwelling, looking up at the bald, bone-dry mountainside.
Some gaps are just matters of disparity.
An entire generation of city kids has grown up hearing "religious" as a synonym for "anxious" or "anti-science." They mistake certain prayer postures for secret signals of defiance against the state. In their books, religion is either reduced to "artistic heritage" or treated as an outdated "critique-worthy" relic, then promptly skipped over.
Communication scholars could chart these biases, labeling them as "stereotypes" or the "absence and distortion" of representation in media.
But up here in the mountains, it becomes a literal thorn piercing the hearts of the old man and his children. After reading those lines in his textbook, the kid quietly asked me, "Are we really the 'feudal superstitions' you guys talk about?"
I was speechless for a moment and had no choice but to change the subject.
Then there are the other beliefs—the ones dug out by people who use the banner of faith to actually worship power itself.
A tiny minority clips thousand-year-old teachings into tools, twisting the concept of a "higher power" to point at themselves. They swap "submission" for absolute cult-like devotion, turn "sacrifice" into fuel for hatred, and hide in the shadows, lighting fires while whispering dark lies into the ears of the people.
Political science and social psychology have long warned us: this kind of extremism is a tumor that can grow in any mass religion. Once it links up with modern communication tools, it spreads just like a virus.
It’s not that the teachings themselves are 'bad'; the real harm comes from any fanatical movement that detaches itself from the land, real-world life, and the country's legal framework.
5
The snow was falling even harder that afternoon, and the Liupan Mountains seemed to recede into the distance, fading into a hazy blur.
I hunched my shoulders against the cold, trekking toward a ridge where a few scattered households remained. The yaodong (traditional cave dwellings) hugged the hillside, looking like squinting eyes, glowing faintly in the snowy light.
The young man walked fast, his boots crunching loudly on the hard-packed snow. As I listened to that rhythm, I thought about all the trendy discussions happening in the cities: cultural clashes, civilizational dialogues, the Sinicization of religion, and localized theology. People in conference rooms talk until their throats are dry and write endless papers, yet they never actually set foot on a mountain path like this.
"How do you feel your faith relates to this country?" I asked, catching up to him.
He paused, smiled, and said, "The country is massive. We practice our faith at home, in our hearts. As long as life is going well, everything is good."
His answer was so simple it felt almost strict, yet it instantly killed any talk of 'opposition' or 'conflict.'
In recent years, many religious scholars have reached a consensus: a truly stable religious life rests on three pillars. First, sticking to the core teachings; second, respecting the laws of the country; and third, rooting oneself in local culture—integrating one's language, religion, and customs into the respect given to this land.
I saw these pillars already standing quietly inside those yaodong. The rough mat on the kang (a traditional heated brick bed), the slightly crooked calligraphy hanging on the wall, the muted-color headscarf on the woman, and the red paper pasted on the door frame—all of them proved that their faith had long ago made peace with the loess soil.
So, whenever people in the city arrogantly claim that 'faith is just an alien, incompatible presence in China,' I always think back to those simple, weathered graves on the ridges and the old man who never misses his daily dua (prayer).
For them, 'China' isn't just an abstract slogan. It’s the flag flying overhead, the government officials from the township climbing the mountains to implement policies a few times a year, the asphalt roads built up to the village, electricity that stays on even in a blizzard, and the faces of children lining up when the national flag is raised at school.
They embrace all of this, along with the spiritual connection they hold in their hearts, as their destiny.
6
I can’t deny that this land has seen bloody years in the past—times when misguided slogans pitted people against one another. There have been failures in understanding religion, leading to awkward, rough, or hurtful actions, which were later recognized and corrected by history.
Historians and social researchers have been reflecting on this for years. Legal and policy journals have seriously discussed 'managing religious affairs according to the law' and 'guaranteeing the right to freedom of belief,' focusing on how to guide the social functions of religion in a stable, rational direction under national leadership.
Standing for a long time before an old, neglected grave, looking at the earth crumbling in the wind, I realize that these reflections on paper are the result of generations carrying heavy burdens to move forward.
If the faith described in this film ever caused 'harm' in China, it was mostly due to the universal human weaknesses: sometimes power uses faith as a tool to incite hatred; sometimes ignorance wraps itself around faith, mixing it with superstition and rumors; and sometimes, bias targets faith to make it a scapegoat, masking deeper social issues.
The 'harm' never grew from the pages of sacred texts; it grew from greed, fear, and ignorance.
Modern neuroscience and social psychology remind us that when a 'group' is constantly highlighted, and when lines are drawn between 'us' and 'them' in discourse, the brain's threat-detection center becomes more active, making people more prone to hostility and suspicion.
This neurological vulnerability isn't specific to religion; it can be triggered by nationalism, class hatred, or even distorted 'cult-like' worship.
Standing on the loess ridge, feeling the wind, I understand this: those with actual responsibility are the ones who hold the power of discourse. If they keep using words like 'conflict,' 'hatred,' and 'generalization' to paint a certain group, that harm will eventually become reality. But if they patiently speak about our shared land, shared history, and shared country, those potential harms can slowly dissolve in the daily smoke of the kitchen chimneys.
7
Night falls quickly in the mountains, and the faint light filtering through the window cracks of the mud-brick huts begins to float up into the darkness.
I stopped for a long time by a dilapidated yaodong at the edge of the village. It had been abandoned for ages, the doorway eroded by the wind, with nothing inside but dirt walls and spiderwebs. Yet, in the memories of the village elders, that cave dwelling once held the secret history of an entire generation.
They say that a group of outsiders once sought refuge in these gullies, quietly reading their scripture inside these cave dwellings during the harshest of winters. On snowy, windy nights, they left behind a few final words of wisdom, urging their descendants never to forget their roots. Eventually, the people passed away or drifted apart, leaving only tiny caves, abandoned graves, and the remnants of snow.
The story isn't specific—it's vague and blurry—but standing in the mountain breeze, it makes me think about all those debates I've read in my study regarding 'martyrdom' and the 'survival of minority traditions.'
From an academic perspective, no religion is just one solid, monolithic block. Instead, it’s made up of countless tiny, localized practices that have spread out over geography and stretched across history. This leads to all sorts of branches: some are peaceful, some are intense, some blend naturally into local customs, and others get caught in a tight, rigid grip within the cracks of society.
Historically speaking, the things that truly bring turmoil to a nation are often the dawn of new movements.
Modern China has spent quite a while figuring out a path: on one hand, it brings all religions under a progressive framework, ensuring that no faith stands above the state or interferes with public power. On the other hand, it keeps space under that same roof for these religions to breathe, allowing them to contribute positive influences like 'cultivating a pure heart,' 'nurturing family and neighborly bonds,' and 'engaging in charity and relief' within the socialist system.
Standing at the entrance of a crumbling cave, I suddenly realized that these institutional compromises aren't just some abstract concepts. They are the actual experiences gained through decades of trial and error in these remote mountains—the state's practical governance in a society of multiple ethnic groups and faiths, dissolving potential 'major problems' through the quiet, consistent work of daily life.
Those who actually cross the line and try to hijack the faith of believers with extremist ideas are dealt with firmly according to the law; meanwhile, ordinary people who follow the rules, prioritize their faith while carrying the country’s support on their shoulders, are folded into a path of common development.
And just like that, the problems are whittled away, millimeter by millimeter.
Eight.
I’ve been traveling this mountain road for years. Every time I leave, stepping through the snow of the Liupan Mountains, I feel a mix of unshakeable anxiety and a stubborn sense of peace.
Someone once asked me, given how many books I’ve read and how many debates I’ve followed about religion versus the state and the clashes between civilizations, what do I actually think about the claim that 'Islam is a detriment to China?'
I found it hard to answer on the spot. Instead, a specific face would always drift into my mind: the elderly person in the Xihaigu wind, the woman silently reciting her dua (prayers) on the kang (heated brick bed), the quiet 'Black Ghost' (a local term of endearment for Hui Muslim neighbors) on the ridge, and that circle of snow on the lonely grave that melts every year only to pile up again.
From a modern scientific perspective, when a great tradition has existed in a major country for over a thousand years, it’s bound to have gone through fusion and conflict, misunderstandings and distortions, and even interventions from external forces.
Sure, there are negatives. Some people might interpret the teachings too narrowly, disrupting the lives of others; a few areas have seen the emergence of extremist undercurrents, casting suspicion on the community; and issues like poverty, lack of education, and limited information access make some young people more susceptible to extreme rhetoric.
You can find all the evidence for these things in social surveys and security reports.
But to say 'Islam is a detriment to China'—as if a single, uniform block could just be dropped onto this nation—I feel that statement itself is a form of prejudice. It’s lazy, and it’s a crude refusal to look at the actual people involved.
More often than not, these 'problems' are man-made. They stem from poor management, unbalanced propaganda, weak education, or unequal development—factors that push a faith which could have been a source of moral guidance for society into an awkward and dangerous corner.
Nine.
At night, looking back from the Liupan Mountains at that vast expanse of dark gullies, only a few scattered lights remain steady in the wind.
Over these years, China has done a lot of real, tangible work in this region: building roads, relocating people, ecological restoration, universalizing compulsory education, bringing medical care to the villages, registering religious venues, and standardizing the training of religious personnel.
When you look at the policies, these changes might seem scattered, but in the villages, they translate into roads for children to walk to school, the confidence to see a doctor without having to sell a sheep, and ceremonies held under the national flag. These experiences let the children in the mountains know that they are both followers of their faith and, at the same time, equally proud citizens.
Sometimes, in the midnight mountain breeze, I ask myself: twenty years from now, when today’s children are too old to sit on the kang and can only bask in the sun against a wall, will they still be bothered by arguments like 'Islam is a detriment to China?'
Or will those debates have been swept away by newer ones? Will people be talking more about how to keep their inner peace in a highly modernized society, or how faith—even in a fast-paced, fluid life—is still willing to bow down to things beyond daily interests? How will we tell the story of China’s multi-ethnic and multi-religious landscape in a globalized world, making it more peaceful and deeply rooted?
Ten.
I don't have the answer; I only know that the loess soil will remember.
The rugged, sun-scorched gullies of the Loess Plateau have, in a sense, simply etched the footprints of generation after generation into their slopes, pressing the echoes of our ancestors deep into the soil; it’s all here—the hunger, the misconceptions, the perseverance, the sacrifices, and the reconciliations—all buried under layer upon layer of dust.
Maybe one day, someone else will follow in my footsteps, braving the wind and snow to step into a weathered cave dwelling. Under the dim, flickering light of a mud-brick room, they might see an old man praying—his back bent low, then slowly straightening up—and that’s when the question will likely hit them again:
When it comes to this land, who has actually been harmed here?
Is it the scriptures brought from the West, or is it those people whose minds have been poisoned by fear and prejudice? Is it the faith itself, or is it just the dark shadow cast when that faith is twisted, used, and misunderstood?
He probably won't be able to articulate it right away, just like me. Stuck in the howling winds of a snowy night in the Liushan mountains, I can only silently take note of these questions and leave them for the future to answer.
I’m never worried about the truth being late, but I am afraid that people are too quick to jump to conclusions they think are right. I fear they’ll just move on, once again lightheartedly forgetting the people behind those flickering little lamps scattered across the Loess Plateau.