Hui Muslim Culture and Heritage: Exploring Identity and Modernity in the Liupan Mountains
While trekking through the snow-covered Liupan Mountains, I took a moment to reflect on the century-long journey of migration and struggle faced by the Hui Muslims in Northwest China. It’s a story of balancing traditional moral values with modern scientific education, finding a way to thrive while stepping onto a broader social stage.
When the snow hit the Liupan Mountains, I found myself standing alone on a frozen dirt road. The wind whipped the snow into fine, thin lines, slicing across the mountainside like shards of sand and gravel. I tucked my head down, my feet tracing that hard-packed path as it stretched from my toes deep into the heart of the charred-yellow hills—it looked like an old, faded scar on the landscape, twisting over the loess hills, refusing to let go.
It’s hard to make conversation in weather like this; the white puffs of breath vanish the second they hit the wind. Yet, all those questions I’ve carried for years started bubbling up, stubbornly refusing to fade away. What does the future look like for the Hui people? In places like Xihaigu—so dry and cracked, filled with loess, deep ravines, lingering snow, and black goats—what kind of future can possibly hide in such ancient shadows?
Layer upon layer, the distant mountains loomed. The snow didn't fully bury them; it just traced a defiant white outline around the waists and ridges of the peaks. The mountain bodies showed their dark-yellow veins, and the ravines carved into the earth as if someone were testing the sharpness of a blade over and over again. I’ve always felt that in this shattered landscape, a people were forced to learn how to grit their teeth, swallow their pain, and bury their words deep into the soil.
City scholars love using neat, tidy words like modernization, urban inclusivity, and cultural identity. They make it look so simple—just draw a few arrows on a chalkboard, and the path forward follows the line. I’ve read some anthropology and sociology books that say the Hui identity in cities is becoming more fluid and diverse. These elders are citizens, believers, and just regular people in the digital age, shifting between halal food and office buildings, weaving their faith, ethnicity, and career into the same coat.
But in Xihaigu, where the bones of the Liupan Mountains are exposed, the identity I’ve seen is more like a pinch of salt in the loess, a crooked little tombstone by a desolate grave, or that old piece of cloth hanging in the corner of a mud-brick house, used for generations to wipe down tables before being washed and hung under smoky eaves. When the wind blows, it flutters like a silent page of scripture.
I remember one deep winter, crossing a ridge from the direction of Shagou. The sky was heavy, and a massive snowfall had blocked the higher roads. My cotton coat was frozen stiff. Looking down from the hillside, the rolling loess plateau of Xihaigu was so quiet under the snow it didn't even seem alive. The ravines had softened into blurry ridges, radiating a terrifying kind of peace. The local villager with me wouldn't speak, only pointing out paths I couldn't see, telling me where a village was, which ridge hid old graves, and which ravine had once washed away houses. Today, it was all so light, as if he were afraid of disturbing something.
In a terrain like this, the word future feels too clear, yet too empty. The loess doesn't care about such words; neither do the passing clouds or the elders in their mud houses who have never left Xihaigu. They only care about when a mountain road will turn to mud, whether the rain will be enough this year, or who in the village can lend money when sickness strikes.
I’ve read the history of the Hui in many thick books—the academic talk about ethnic observation and symbolic boundaries. They say that while the Hui have always been rooted in this land, they’ve also stretched their hearts toward the distant Islamic world through religious study (jingtang), the pilgrimage (hajj), and ancient trade routes. Some scholars talk about collective belonging as a way of connecting to the state, describing a dual identity where they negotiate their language, diet, marriage, and spiritual path to form a unique ethnic character.
But once these theories are blown away by the plateau wind, my focus turns back to the small, slow moments of real life.
That winter, as the snow deepened, I stayed in a village at the foot of a hill. The village was huddled between two ridges, with dozens of cave dwellings (yaodong) carved into the loess slopes. Old wooden beams supported the doorways, and the winter wind circled the cave mouths, making the old calendars hanging on the doors flap incessantly. The yellow mud hut was dark in the snow—it wasn't the abstract image you find in books, but a shell where someone had squeezed their whole life inside. It smelled of coal smoke and the damp steam rising from a stove fueled by cow dung, with quilts folded neatly on the (a heated brick bed) and the frost-bitten hands of children.
The head of the house was a quiet Hui man whose face was chapped by the mountain wind and whose beard was often crusted with frost. A goat in the corner was half-asleep, its horns catching the dim light of the lamp. I remember it clearly: under that small light, his wife was mending the children’s cotton pants. The stove was small, the heat only reaching the edge of the bed. It was so cold my socks felt numb. The man handed me a bowl of strong guanguan cha (a traditional tea brewed in a small clay pot), but he didn't talk about the hardship in his own house. Instead, he spoke of whose kid had been accepted into a city school this year and which girl had learned a trade outside and returned to the village to teach others.
There was an unaccustomed joy in his voice, a kind of raw, unfamiliar pride. Thinking of those children who had ventured out—who didn't completely belong to their small hut anymore—I sat on the soot-blackened mud bed, looking at that rugged face in the dim light. I had a strange feeling in my heart. All those phrases from city sociologists—upward educational mobility, intergenerational career shifts—melted into this man’s simple words: My kids are doing well; I’m happy.
In that moment, I realized that the future of the Hui isn't found in the books of writers or professors, nor in academic jargon or development plans. It’s hidden in these small, earthy transformations: in the electric light flickering on inside a cave dwelling, in a girl walking from a mountain ravine to become a nurse in a city hospital, and in a teenager practicing the English alphabet in a classroom while, outside the window, a construction truck slowly levels the frozen earth.
Some say modernization will dilute the traditions of the Hui, grinding down the religious rules (Qingzhen traditions) and making this ethnic group blend into the surrounding majority, losing its edge. In the cities I’ve visited, I’ve seen signs of this. High-rises built on both sides of a halal street block the light from the old houses; young people stare at their phones, their accents shifting to a standard Mandarin; and in the lunch lines, teenagers with dyed hair crouch in rows, their heads bowed low.
I don't want to criticize or praise this too easily. I only remember what some scholars said: that modern life doesn't necessarily have to mean the disappearance of tradition; it could be a different kind of celebration. For example, turning the halal concept into a mark of quality, turning festivals into a way to bring family together, or incorporating ancient values like cleanliness, temperance, and reverence into modern professional ethics. Let an engineer be more meticulous, let a merchant refuse to cut corners on the scales—to others, these might not seem like grand statements, but they give me a bit more patience when looking at this loess earth.
The history of the Hui on the Loess Plateau remembers much, but it also lets much slip away. History books record the major wars and the moments of heroic resistance, the way people were swept up in the tides of chaos. But the loess remembers something else: it remembers nameless women brewing soup in the middle of winter, teenagers gritting their teeth to carry headstones for the deceased up the mountain, and generations protecting desolate graves from being trampled by livestock. Academics call this silent martyrdom memory, noting that in many Hui communities, people don't talk much about the old tragedies, but instead pass down respect and oaths for their ancestors through festivals and family trees.
One winter day in Xihaigu, I followed some villagers to clear snow from the graves on the hillside. The mountains were sealed by heavy snow, and the wind howled across the ridge. The graves were just slightly raised mounds of earth, blurred into a single line by the snow. The adults used brooms to carefully push the snow aside, finding the frozen loess beneath. They didn't say a word, just an occasional cough. I clumsily followed along, my fingers developing callouses from the rough sorghum broom. Yet, in that silent act, I understood better than any slogan what this group’s attitude was toward their history and the land they lived on.
Once, as I walked away from a mountain bay, I saw a row of abandoned cave dwellings on the loess cliff. The entrances were pitch black, like eyes of the mountain. I stood there for a long time, feeling as if there were secrets left unsaid in those ruins. Were the souls who lived here for generations beckoning or waving goodbye? I couldn't figure it out. After studying a bit of ethnology, I developed this habit of seeing everything as a text—trying to write about symbols, structures, and the sociological concept of embedded knowledge and change. But as I traveled more, I realized this kind of interpretation is dangerous.
The danger is that one might easily stand in a superior position, thinking they have understood the local discourse or dismantled their faith, trying to slap a few theories onto them to speak on their behalf. I don't want that. I’d rather admit there is much I don't understand. For example, I don't understand an elderly mother clearing snow from a grave every year—if she didn't clear it, would it really matter? How do they view the successes and failures of this world? I don't understand the inner peace of an old man who has been poor his whole life during his prayer (dua). I don't understand the young Hui entrepreneurs in the city, wearing trendy skullcaps, balancing their ledgers and the classics, carefully managing their dual identities.
Standing on this snowy road in the Liupan Mountains, I keep thinking about these people. They are the hardest part to write about when it comes to the future of the Hui, but they are also the most critical. Because they aren't slogans or rows of numbers on a spreadsheet; they are the path itself. They are the little sprigs of grass stubbornly poking through the cracks in the loess plateau—growing slowly in the mud, but rising up against the wind year after year.
Scholars love to ask where the future of the Hui lies: is it deeper integration into modern cities, faster education, stronger industries, or more extensive economic ties? These arguments are all valid, and the state has certainly been guiding things in this direction with policies and planning. In recent years, in areas where Hui Muslims gather in the Northwest, poverty alleviation has made strides, and education and healthcare have improved. New village construction is slowly replacing mud houses with brick buildings. Many scholars in the field see that life today is vastly different from the struggles their parents described.
When you pass by these new houses, you feel a sense of stability. People deserve better homes, brighter lamps, and stronger roads. Whether children study in warm classrooms rather than freezing their hands writing under the light of a dim lamp is the future of an entire group, and it shouldn't be held hostage by sandstorms and hunger. These changes are a tangible gift to this land.
But I also have a vague worry. My fear is that during these necessary and justified changes, if that spirit of cleanliness—forged in the struggles of the past—gets diluted, it would be a shame. The cleanliness I’m thinking of isn't just about ritual prohibitions or being against anyone; it’s the sense of integrity the Hui developed through brief moments of hardship, restraint, and vigilance. It’s about knowing where the line is drawn, knowing when to stop, not being willing to live recklessly even in poverty, and maintaining a sense of uprightness even when one is few in number and weak in influence.
You can't see this with the naked eye; you can only sense it in the little things. It’s hidden in the language of a merchant who refuses to short-change a customer, in the way elders treat the younger generation, and in the unwritten community rules. Some sociology books call this internal ethical resource, a vital capital for participating in national and social life within a modern society. I’d rather use a humbler term: Kindness and Backbone.
Discover the resilience of Hui Muslims in Northwest China as they navigate modern life, blending cultural heritage and faith along the snowy trails of Mount Liupan. Figuring out the path forward for Hui Muslims isn't just about escaping poverty or checking off development goals; it's about keeping pace with modern life without losing your backbone, a journey that can't be found in a textbook or copy-pasted from somewhere else.
Back in the city, I've run into some young Hui Muslim intellectuals who finished college, went on to study Islamic theology, and later picked up public administration. In class, they chat about national identity and civil society, but on the weekends, they head back to their home villages to chat with folks about disease prevention, legal basics, and helping the elderly fill out forms. Their grasp of Islamic teachings might not be as sharp as the old imams, and their suits might not fit quite right, but they carry this deeply grounded vibe, like they're trying to stitch two totally different worlds together into one solid piece of fabric.
I always feel like folks like this are walking along a super narrow and risky ridge, with ice on one side, fog on the other, and hard earth mixed with city pavement under their feet. Half of them are rooting their foundation deep in the loess soil, while the other half are building a bridge up in the air. If those bridges stay steady, the path forward for Hui Muslims will open up even more.
The latest anthropology research always reminds us not to pigeonhole any ethnic group into a rigid, uniform box. Within any community, you've got a whole mix of paths: farmers holding it down in the villages, workers and migrants hustling in the cities, intellectuals reading and writing, and elders offering silent dua (supplications). All these different paths come together to form a living community rather than forcing everyone to look the exact same way.
During the winter in Xihaigu, as I walked over those frozen dirt roads again and again, the Hui Muslims I met were living out this vibrant mix of everyday life: elders holding onto traditional religious teachings in mud-brick homes, teenagers herding mountain goats across the ridges, young couples running small shops in town, girls singing pop songs on short-form video apps, and students in county schools who are super curious about the world yet still a bit lost. Every single one of these folks is asking the exact same question: Where do we go from here?
When they ask, they often use big abstract words like finding a way out, or they just talk about how life is going, whether things can get a bit easier, or where the kids will end up settling down. Behind that simple talk is the real heartbeat of an ethnic community facing modernization, the vast earth, and the nation. These thoughts are the same whether you share them with your Han neighbors, teachers from the city, visiting officials, scholars taking notes in their notebooks, or someone like me standing out here in the snow.
Late at night, the lights in the village mud-brick houses flicker out one by one, leaving just a couple of faint glows tucked away in the mountain hollows like dying embers on a vast landscape. I lay wide-awake on the traditional brick kang (heated bed) inside the cave dwelling, listening to the wind whipping snow against the stone cliffs with a rustling sound. All those stories I heard during the day kept playing in my head—some happy, some bitter, some full of fresh hope, and some bearing old wounds. It's pretty tough for me to tie a neat bow on their past or hand over some grand conclusion.
The way forward for Hui Muslims shouldn't be boxed into some grand century-long blueprint written by thinkers. I'm more and more convinced that it just slowly reveals itself over time—unfolding across decades of wider roads, newly built schools, and lit-up hospitals, showing up in how generations view their land, their faith, and their country, and taking shape in countless everyday choices.
Out there in the snowy night, a thought suddenly hit me. Years ago, somewhere else up north, I saw a big river rushing along—muddy, freezing cold, and fast, with chunks of ice grinding against the surface and making a deep rumbling sound. Standing on the bank, I felt this instant respect for the river, seeing it as wild, tough, and silent, dragging generations along its banks toward the future. Standing now on the high slopes of Xihaigu, I realized the loess soil here is basically an invisible river too—a motionless river running through the long flow of time, slowly squeezing every generation and pushing them from barrenness into a wider world, from cramped spaces into much bigger horizons.
The path forward for Hui Muslims basically means moving right along with this river of loess soil—staying deeply rooted while keeping on the move, acting as down-to-earth builders while holding onto that clean backbone of self-respect. As we work together with everyone to build a shared life, we can weave our unique cultural flair right into the foundation of civilization.
As dawn was about to break, the local fellow sharing the brick bed tossed and turned, muttering some mumbled words in his sleep. The wind outside the window calmed down a bit. I knew the snow-covered roads would be even trickier to navigate, with icy patches on the mountains and crumbly edges along the gullies. I had to hit the road early, or I'd get stuck on this loess plateau gently sealed off by snow, just like a lost traveler.
I threw on my cotton jacket and quietly stepped out of the cave dwelling. Beneath my boots came a crisp crunch in the snow. Everything between earth and sky was glowing white, with Mount Liupan standing silent in the distant fog, and the mud-brick houses shrinking into tiny clusters below my shoulders. I looked back for a long time, like staring at an unfinished chapter. I knew that once the kids in these families grew up, the old ways would have to shift—mud-brick would swap for brick and stone, coal smoke for clean lighting, and the edge of the kang for tables and chairs. I wonder if those mud-brick houses ever ponder their own changes, or maybe they're just places where people live, no matter what form they take!
I honestly don't know how the folks who tear down these mud-brick houses will talk about their childhoods later on, or how they'll view the paths their fathers took. I don't know if they'll say the words 'I am Hui' softly, with total certainty, out of pure habit, or carrying some kind of hidden pride.
Nobody can guess any of that for sure. All I know is that no matter what, before that day finally arrives, someone has to keep walking this trail step by step, stretching from the foot of Mount Liupan and across the gullies of Xihaigu. Someone has to keep moving forward steadily through the wind and snow, leaving firm footprints right in the loess soil.
As for what lies at the very end of the road—whether it's bigger cities, education that never gets lost, a life that embraces diversity while staying pure, or some shared future we don't even have a name for yet—I'm not making any calls today. I'm leaving that big question mark right in the hands of the rising generation.
They'll use their own words to answer this question that's as old as time yet brand new: right here in these loess mountains, amid the snowed-in peaks, mud-brick houses, dark hills, and remnants of graves under melting snow, how will a community called Hui Muslims carve out their own path, and just like all other ethnic groups, how will they turn this trail into a truly wide and open road across the land?
I stood out in the snow for a little bit, watching my breath slowly fade into the air. A faint streak of light appeared on the horizon, and the long road along Mount Liupan stretched onward, not handing me any easy answers, but simply pressing that ongoing question into every heavy, crunching step under my feet. The road kept right on going with me toward a distant horizon we still can't quite see.